Are you in the market for high-end sheets that won’t break the bank, or would you rather spend your money on a pair of premium sheets from an ultra sustainable and environmentally friendly brand? In this post, we discuss the in’s and out’s of the most popular sheets from Boll and Branch and Brooklinen in order to help you decide which one you think is best.

Boll And Branch vs Brooklinen

If you’re in the market for high-end sheets that won’t break the bank or premium sheets from an ultra sustainable and environmentally friendly brand, then you’ve come to the right place to learn the in’s and out’s of the most popular sheets from Boll & Branch and Brooklinen.

Boll and Branch vs Brooklinen are two top-rated bedding brands with direct-to-consumer business models that deliver high-quality sheets to all kinds of sleepers. The brands have different values, which is one of the major things that set them apart from each other.

Boll and Branch is dedicated to being organic and sustainable, while Brooklinen strives to make top-quality products for a price that’s more accessible to everyone. We think both brands are impressive, but your choice will ultimately come down to what you think is and isn’t important (materials, price, sourcing, etc.).

Here’s a quick overview of each brand:

  • Materials – The Boll & Branch Classic Hemmed sheets use long-staple organic cotton while Brooklinen Luxe sheets use standard long-staple cotton.
  • Thread Count – The Boll & Branch Classic Hemmed sheets have a 300-thread count and Brooklinen Luxe sheets have a 480-thread count.
  • Price – Boll & Branch’s Classic Hemmed queen sheets retail for $240 while Brooklinen Luxe queen sheets are around $159 without discounts applied.
  • Company Values – Boll & Branch commits to sustainable and ethical practices, but Brooklinen offers impressive policies not often seen with many bedding accessory products.

We’ll mainly focus on Boll and Branch’s Classic Hemmed set and Brooklinen’s Luxe Sateen set because those styles are the most popular from each brand. Now that we’ve got that out of the way, let’s get into the heart of this review! For help navigating this comparison, use our jump-to links below.

Boll And Branch Sheets
Boll And Branch Sheets
Why it’s Great
Boll and Branch sheets are made with premium, organic cotton and have a super-soft, breathable feel.
Product Details
Free Shipping
and returns
Trial Period
30 Nights


Check Current Offers

Boll And Branch’s Sheet Set Materials

Boll Branch Luxury Bedding Sheets Overview
The clean look of Boll and Branch’s best selling sheets

The Classic Hemmed sheets from Boll & Branch are the brand’s top seller, made with long-staple organic cotton and a sateen weave that’s meant to give them a slight glossy, sheen finish. This comfy combo makes the sheets feel super soft and extra breathable, since organic cotton is a cooler sleeping material than standard cotton. You can tell they’re luxury sheets upon first touch.

Classic Hemmed Sheet Specs

Now let’s get into a few of the Classic Hemmed set’s highlight specs:

  • 300-thread count
  • Woven organic cotton
  • 17” deep pockets with an elastic band that goes all the way around the bed sheet

These sheets might fit a little big the first time you put them on. But don’t worry, you didn’t order the wrong size. It’s completely intentional.

Boll & Branch focuses on organic farming and manufacturing (we’ll get into this more in the next section), which means the sheets aren’t pre-shrunk with any harsh chemicals, brightening qualities or added dyes. The ill fitting sheets are better in the long run — just throw them in the washer and dryer before using them. After one or two washes, the sheets should start fitting around your mattress like a glove.

They’re available in a range of neutral and cool colors, and come in seven sizes—  twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, California king and split king.

The Brand’s Commitment To The Environment

Boll and Branch Luxury Bedding Sheets Ethically Sourced
Boll and Branch is one of the most ethical companies we’ve seen

Not only does Boll & Branch use organic cotton in their sheets, they’re also devoted to using organic and environmentally-friendly practices every step of the way. Their organic cotton is sourced from sustainable farms where the workers are fairly compensated and are working under safe, ethical working conditions.

Thanks to their choice to support organic farming, they have:

  • Saved a whopping 592,923,320 gallons of water
  • Made packaging material that is 100% recycled and can be re-purposed
  • Reduced carbon emissions by 21,252 metric tons (which is the same as saving emissions from 4,500 cars a year) by transporting materials using a cargo ship as opposed to planes or trains
  • Made 100% of their products without using harmful chemicals, pesticides or GMOs
  • Kept 12,800 farmers out of debt by buying 2.4 million pounds of Fair Trade seed cotton
  • Been named the first Fair Trade certified manufacturer of linens
  • Paid close to $500,000 in additional wages to both farmers and factory workers to sustain living wages

The factories that manufacture Boll & Branch products are carefully chosen to make sure workers are of age (absolutely no child labor), make sustainable, livable wage, and are working in safe conditions.

Brooklinen Sheets
Brooklinen Sheets
Why it’s Great
Brooklinen is one of the largest online bedding companies. The brand is primarily known for their sheets, which come in multiple color options, patterns, and textiles.
Best for
People that like options (Brooklinen has many of them)
If you’re worried you might not like them (free returns)
Sleep Positions
Back, Side and Stomach
Product Details
Free Shipping
and returns
Trial Period
365 Nights

10%  use code:  SLUMBERYARD10  in cart

10% Off

Brooklinen Sheet Set And Materials

brooklinen sheets 3
The smoke stripe pattern on Brooklinen’s Luxe Sateen sheets

Brooklinen’s Luxe Sateen Sheet Set is their best seller and you can see why after you sleep on them. They’re made with OEKO-TEX certified long-staple cotton with a sateen weave, meaning they’re free of toxic chemicals. They aren’t quite as breathable as Boll and Branch’s sheets considering Brooklinen doesn’t use organic cotton, but the Luxe sheets are still luxurious and comfortable. Like Boll and Branch, we think they’d be suitable for a five-star luxury hotel.

Brooklinen Luxe Sateen Specs

  • 480-thread count
  • 15” deep pockets
  • Available in a range of standard colors, from white to dark navy blue, as well as different color patterns

If you’re looking for more fun-looking sheets, Brooklinen has a few more options to choose from. However, they don’t have a split king sheet set option like Boll & Branch offers. Instead, they have twin, twin XL, full, queen, king and California king.

Boll And Branch vs Brooklinen Company Policies

Brooklinen Sheets Review Pinstripes Unboxing
Unboxing the Brooklinen Luxe Sateen sheets

Brooklinen may not go as far as Boll and Branch in being ultra sustainable, but they do go above and beyond for their customers. They stand by their products and are certainly impressed with their company policies.

  • Brooklinen offers a full 365 nights to try out your sheets, while Boll and Branch offers 30 days
  • Brooklinen sheets come with a lifetime warranty, compared to Boll and Branch, who doesn’t necessarily have a set warranty policy.

This means Brooklinen will cover certain parts of your sheets for the entire time you own them — whether it’s five years or 50 years, and you have an entire year to test out your Brooklinen sheets vs Boll and Branch’s 30-day offer.

Boll And Branch vs Brooklinen: Comparing Price Tags

Size Boll & Branch Classic HemmedBrooklinen Luxe Sateen
Twin  $160 $139
Twin XL  $190 $139
Full  $220 $159
Queen  $240 $159
King/Cal King  $250/$260 $189
Split King  $295 

Both brands make premium products, but Brooklinen focuses on making quality and affordable sheets, while Boll and Branch is committed to being organic and sustainable. Typically, organic means a higher price tag and Boll& Branch is the pricier of the two options.

If you’re on an even tighter budget, Brooklinen also offers Classic Percale sheets, which start at $109, or even less if you purchase during a promotion. For Boll and Branch, prices only go up if you’re interested in their different fabrics.

Final Thoughts: Boll And Branch Or Brooklinen?

Hopefully, we’ve helped you get a little closer to your decision between Brooklinen vs Boll and Branch. If not, consider the following questions:

  • Do you prioritize sustainability and eco-friendly practices? Boll & Branch is all about being environmentally conscious and sustainable.
  • Are you looking for the best bang for your buck? Brooklinen is more affordable, but is still of high quality.
  • Would you rather spend more on organic products? Boll and Branch uses organic cotton in all of their sheet fabrics.
  • Do you prefer softer or breathable sheets? Brooklinen has slightly softer sheets, while Boll & Branch is a little more breathable.

You usually can’t go wrong buying a pair of luxury sheets — we honestly think either one you choose will feel ultra luxurious and comfortable. It all comes down to the specific details you find important, like thread count, materials, sourcing/manufacturing and price.

Thanks for stopping by the Slumber Yard! Feel free to check out our individual reviews on Boll & Branch and Brooklinen to find out more about their different sheet sets, plus other information that wasn’t included in this comparison.

Review team

  • kenzie
    McKenzie Dillon

    Combo Sleeper

  • Jeff Rizzo
    Jeff Rizzo

    Combo Sleeper

  • Owen Poole

    Side Sleeper

  • JD
    JD Christison

    Combo Sleeper

How do I wash my sheets?

Wash your sheets on a gentle cycle with mild detergent using cold or cool water. Do not use bleach. Use a low heat, low tumble setting for the dryer and remove promptly when they’re dry.

Which ones are more expensive?

Boll and Branch’s most popular sheets are more expensive than Brooklinen’s most popular. Boll and Branch’s queen sized Classic Hemmed sheets are $240, while Brooklinen’s Luxe Sateen are $159, a difference of $81.

Who has the higher thread count?

Brooklinen offers a thread count of 480, while Boll & Branch’s is 300.

How is Boll and Branch environmentally friendly?

Boll & Branch uses cargo ships to transport its products instead of planes or trains, saving 21,252 metric tons of cargo emissions, the equivalent of emissions from 4,500 cars. The company does not use insecticides or pesticides on its cotton. Additionally, organic cotton uses less water, resulting in a savings of 592,923,320 gallons of water a year.