Best Hybrid And Innerspring Mattress
So you’ve started the search for your next mattress. It’s overwhelming, isn’t it? Chances are, you haven’t done this for about seven years and things have really changed since your last trip to the local mattress store. We commend you for doing your due diligence in mattress research beforehand, and have put together a list of our top choices for the best hybrid mattress to make the process a little easier for you. We’ve reviewed and tested well over 150 mattresses, and have extensive knowledge about mattresses and the bed-in-a-box industry itself. As such, we think we have a good grip on which mattresses stand out from the rest of the pack.
Hybrid and innerspring beds are typically known for their durability and support, and believe us, all of the beds below offer those two major criteria points and more! Below is a navigation tool to help you jump to sections you want to read the most. Otherwise, continue on to our best list for the best hybrid mattress 2020.
Jump-To Links For This Best Hybrid Mattress List
The Slumber Yard team has tested over 150 mattresses and we’re no newcomers to hybrid mattress reviews. Our aim here is to give you accurate information, so we test all our mattresses via practical methods and make sure to consider how different people will experience each bed. We also have complete control over our content. All of our opinions are 100% our own.
We have tried to spread the love between inner spring mattresses and hybrid mattresses for this list. That means that we have beds with traditional springs and new-age pocket coils. Not only that, but our editors specifically looked for beds that fit with consumer demand trends. For instance, we made sure to choose a firm innerspring mattress alongside several hybrid bed in a box mattresses. These are the best rated beds in their respective category, and are all available online.
Video Review For Best Hybrid Bed
Top 7 Best Hybrid Mattresses
After careful research and deliberation over factors such as cost, body types, sleep positions, and the balance of soft versus firm, these seven were chosen as the best hybrid mattresses.
Best Value For The Money –Brooklyn Bedding Signature
Best Innerspring Mattress –Saatva Classic
Great For Hot Sleepers –Purple Hybrid Premier 3
Best Mattress In A Box –Bear Hybrid
Best Plush Hybrid Mattress –WinkBeds Classic
Best Firm Hybrid Mattress –Avocado Vegan Mattress
Memory Foam Mattress –DreamCloud
Brooklyn Bedding Signature – Best Value For The Money
Starting off our hybrid mattress reviews is the Brooklyn Bedding Signature mattress; an accommodating pocketed coil mattress that comes in multiple firmness levels, allowing shoppers to choose which one is best suited for their sleeping position. You get a soft foam feel (more neutral, not like memory foam), as well as ample support from the pocketed coil base layer.
This premium bed in a box mattress also offers a great value. Typically, you can get a queen size bed for under $850, which is the same price as many all-foam mattresses in the market.
We Brooklyn Bedding Signature was chosen – Ultimately, the choice of firmness levels, along with the hybrid construction with pocket springs, make Brooklyn’s Signature mattress a good value bed for a wide range of body and sleeper types. Plus, Brooklyn actually manufactures their own beds so the Signature isn’t going to break the bank because they aren’t charging you more to deal with a middleman.
Saatva – Best Innerspring Mattress
Saatva is our top pick in our hybrid mattress reviews, thanks to its innerspring and pocketed coil base layers. That’s right, there are back-to-back systems for maximum durability and bi-directional support.
With the organic cotton cover and Euro pillow top, the bed gets a bit of cushioning, too. Though it’s still quite firm if you go with the Luxury Firm or Firm comfort level.
Saatva is actually available in three comfort profiles: Plush Soft, Luxury Firm, and Firm. Side sleepers should opt for the Plush Soft model, while Luxury Firm and Firm should be reserved for back and stomach sleepers.
Why we chose Saatva – If you want the best innerspring mattress online, Saatva is probably the way to go. For starters, it has proper innersprings for its main support base, and an additional layer of pocketed coils above it for maximum support. And although it’s considered a luxury mattress, it’s price tag is very reasonable. Saatva is about $1,400 for the queen, but you can check the price on Saatva.com.
Purple Hybrid – Great For Hot Sleepers
Purple is our top selection for the best hybrid mattress for hot sleepers. Purple mattresses have been somewhat of a game changer in the mattress in a box industry because they’re unlike anything else out there.
And since the Purple Hybrid mattresses added coils to the construction, they’re all-around accommodating beds for all body types—assuming you like the unique feel (and not everyone does).
Purple uses the usual materials, like pocketed coils and poly foam, but they also have a grid layer of Hyper-Elastic Polymer and that’s what makes their beds stand out. It’s a really responsive material that provides pressure relief and really great airflow. You can learn more about the material on Purple.com.
Plus, you still get plenty of support from the foam and coil layers. To figure out which model (Purple Hybrid, Purple Hybrid Premier 3 or Purple Hybrid Premier 4) is right for you, you can check out our Purple Mattress Comparison where we break it all down. You can also check out our full Purple mattress review for more info.
Why we chose Purple – If you want the best coil spring mattress for hot sleepers, as much as we like other beds, we think Purple is just the obvious, no-brainer pick. We can’t promise that it will work for everyone, but you’re not afraid to try something new, there’s a good chance you’ll be very happy with a Purple mattress because if offers so much airflow and comfort.
Bear Hybrid – Best Mattress In A Box
Bear is a reputable brand who offers a few different mattress models, but we love Bear Hybrid for a number of reasons.
This mattress offers a supportive pocketed coil base and thick fluffy pillow top in the comfort layers, with a medium firmness level to accommodate all sleeper positions.
It also has a Celliant-infused cover, a type of technology that only a handful of mattresses offer. Celliant technology has been tested and proven to promote healthy circulation, muscle recovery, and restful sleep (according to the manufacturers of Celliant).
The Bear Hybrid mattress is an insanely comfortable bed—the kind of bed that makes you say “aaahhh” when you hit the sack at the end of the day. We actually think it’s Bear’s best bed, and certainly among the best coil spring mattresses on the market today thanks to its unique Celliant-infused design and affordable price tag.
WinkBed – Best Plush Hybrid Mattress
Like Saatva, this mattress has an ultra supportive and durable design with a pocketed coil layer, and a microcoil layer on top. The brand actually takes pride in being incredibly durable, and offer a lifetime warranty to back their product. Not to mention it looks great in your bedroom, there’s no denying WinkBed is a high-end mattress.
It offers three different firmness levels, one of which is more plush and great for side sleepers who want an extra pressure relieving mattress.
And, if you’re heavy or overweight, you might want to look into WinkBed Plus, which is designed just for heavy people—that weigh up to about 450 lb. You can check WinkBeds.com to see all the models and prices.
Why we added WinkBed – WinkBed is a hotel luxury product that appeals to a wide range of sleeper types. WinkBed is constantly topping our best lists because of its second-to-none design, and it checks a ton of boxes for someone who’s looking to invest in a supportive hybrid mattress.
Avocado – Best Firm Hybrid Mattress
If you’re environmentally conscious and you want a bed with hypoallergenic and antimicrobial properties with a firm profile, look no further. This bed is made with organic cotton, organic latex foam, and New Zealand wool. It even has recycled coil springs in the base layer. As for certifications, it seemingly has them all. Its cotton is certified organic (GOTS). It’s latex foam is certified organic (GOLS). And the entire bed is GREENGUARD Gold Certified by the UL Environment.
Avocado measures about 11” thick and is a truly firm innerspring mattress. For more money, however, you can make it a hybrid pillow top mattress that’s a good deal less firm. It won’t end up being plush, but the pillow top does make it around a medium-firm and acceptable for all sleeping styles.
Given that Avocado has the coils and organic foam, it has a highly responsive/resilient feel. You won’t get the deep contouring effect that you will with other beds, but if all you’re after is a firm hybrid mattress, we fully expect that you’ll really like Avocado.
Considering all that Avocado offers, our editors are of the opinion that it’s one of the best mattresses for the money. Last we checked, the queen bed was well under the $2K mark.
We Avocado was added – Avocado was our editor’s first choice as the best firm mattress, but it’s so much more than that. Flat out, this is one of the best rated mattresses online—and we can completely understand why. In our reviews, we have almost nothing negative to bring up about Avocado. It’s good for your sleep if you’re a back or stomach sleeper, and good for the environment, too!
DreamCloud – Best Memory Foam Hybrid Mattress
DreamCloud Premier is our #1 pick for the best hybrid memory foam mattress. It’s a supportive coil spring mattress with plenty of cushion, such that you can sleep in just about any position.
DreamCloud Premier is also a hefty mattress at about 15″ thick. It has five layers of foam materials and a layer of 8″ pocket coils. It doesn’t have as dense/viscous of a feel as a traditional TempurPedic mattress because of its fluffy pillow top comfort layer, but you can tell that this is in fact a memory foam mattress thanks to its pressure relieving properties.
In terms of firmness, we consider DreamCloud Premier to be somewhere between a medium and medium-firm, which is why we say all sleeping positions are fine. While firmness is subjective, suffice it to say that DreamCloud Premier is not a soft hybrid mattress—if anything, it skews more toward being a firm innerspring mattress.
Why DreamCloud was chosen – We have a big DreamCloud fanatic in our office (Dillon) and we all agree that DreamCloud Premier is a great memory foam mattress. It might even work for those who dislike traditional memory foam because it offers a more new-age feel that honestly very comfortable. It’s also made with premium materials, and will accommodate most individuals besides some petite side sleepers.
Why Trust Us
Get the kind of sleep you’ve only dreamed of with some help from our team of mattress experts. We personally test more than 150 of the best sleep solutions from over 60 leading brands on site, so you can be sure you’re getting unbiased reviews, fair comparisons and personalized recommendations.
Hybrid vs Innerspring Mattress
What is an innerspring mattress and what is a hybrid mattress? The easiest explanation here is that a hybrid mattress almost always has an innerspring or pocketed coil base, but an innerspring mattress doesn’t necessarily have to be a hybrid.
Just like how a Toyota Prius runs on both gas and electric, a hybrid mattress is made out of two dissimilar materials to achieve a certain feel. Hybrid mattresses utilize two different materials; usually, it’s innersprings and some type of foam, such as memory foam, latex foam, or polyurethane foam (a.k.a. neutral-foam).
Innerspring mattresses are beds that have coils as a support base. It’s likely that there’s an innerspring mattress in your grandma’s guest bedroom or somewhere in the back corner of your garage collecting dust. That isn’t to say they aren’t good mattresses, they’re just very traditional.
Now-a-days, you see a lot more hybrid mattresses with pocket springs online because they can tend to help isolate motion better. You still get a lot of support, but with reduced motion transfer, which is, objectively, a good thing.
Different Types Of Coil Mattresses
There are two basic construction types for mattresses nowadays: all-foam and hybrid mattresses. Interestingly enough, hybrid technically encompasses both inner spring mattresses and pocket coil beds mattresses. The difference between them is:
- Inner spring mattresses have a coil support structure that’s more traditional. It’s basically one big steel chasis.
- Pocketed coil mattresses also use spring supports, but they are individually wrapped in fabric and move somewhat independently from one another to help improve motion isolation.
Who Are Hybrid Mattresses Good For?
Now that you know what a hybrid and innerspring mattress is, why would somebody purchase one? For starters, typically they’re ideal for those who are looking for a little extra support — i.e. heavy sleepers, folks with back pain, or back and stomach sleepers.
The pocket coils work together to provide localized support, and the bed as a whole can tend to hold up longer for heavier folks than an all-foam bed will. It’s not always the case, but typically for a heavy person, a coil spring mattress is a better idea because of the bounce-back and bi-directional support.
Hybrid vs Foam Mattress
An all-foam mattress is exactly that, a mattress made from multiple foam layers. We’ve reviewed a ton of all-foam beds on this site like Tuft and Needle or Casper Mattress. They’re definitely comfortable, but there’s a reason why a majority of brands are also releasing hybrid models of their mattresses.
Hybrid beds tend to offer up more support than all-foam mattresses because of the coil units. For a heavier person, typically a 12” hybrid mattress will last longer, and feel more supportive than a 12” all-foam mattress. Also, because they are coil spring mattresses, they have the extra bounce factor, especially if the system of innersprings is paired with a layer or two of latex foam.
Additionally, if you’re a hot sleeper, hybrid mattresses can sometimes help you sleep more temperature neutral than some all-foam beds—especially if you’re sleeping on a traditional, viscous memory foam mattress.
Common Foam Materials
Online mattresses are made with a variety of different materials and what goes into the construction determines the feel and firmness of the bed.
Memory Foam — Memory foam is a denser foam that softens over time and when heat is applied. You’ll get that sink-in feeling if you lay in one spot. For some people, this feels like being comfortably cradled, but for others it’s like being stuck.
Polyurethane Foam — Poly foam is usually used as the support for all-foam mattresses because it’s affordable and comes in many different densities. As a general rule, the denser it is, the firmer it feels. It’s just slightly cooler than memory foam, but this depends on the density, as well. It generally has a lower point elasticity than memory foam, so when you press on one area, it affects a larger area.
Gel Memory Foam — Gel memory foam is a newer technology that incorporates gel into the foam to boost temperature regulation. Basically, it helps cool people down. It’s not a perfect solution, though, because the bed can still warm up a bit.
Latex Foam — It has more of a sponge-like feeling. It’s very bouncy and airy and stays cooler than memory foam. Here’s our list of the best latex mattresses. If you get one of these beds, you might want to think about a king size mattress if you are sharing it with a partner—they are quite responsive and bouncy.
Gel/Hyper-Elastic Polymer — This material is heavy and feels odd, but is great for airflow, responsiveness, pressure relief, and support. It also tends to have high point elasticity (i.e. press on one area and it doesn’t spread too much to the other side of the mattress), which makes for low cross-bed motion.
“Sleeper type” refers to the position you sleep in—on your back or stomach, on your side, or a combination of all of them. And your sleeper type plays a pretty significant role in what kind of bed you should be sleeping on.
Back and stomach sleepers Those who sleep on their backs and stomachs generally need a mattress that’s on the firmer side. They need extra support so that their hips and shoulders don’t sag and cause alignment issues for their spine and hips. Here are two related best lists: Best Mattress for Back Sleepers and Best Mattress for Stomach Sleepers. We’ve made a selection of the best firm innerspring mattress with these types of sleepers in mind.
Side sleeping People who sleep on their sides tend to prefer a bed between soft and medium-firm on the firmness scale (depending on body type). When you sleep on your side, you need plenty of pressure relief in the shoulders and hips. If the bed is too firm, you’ll have issues with your shoulders, scapula, and hips. Here’s our list of the best hybrid mattress for side sleepers. We have tested everything from plush hybrid mattresses to firm innerspring mattresses, and basically everything in between. Typically, side sleepers will gravitate toward the plush mattress. Still, we have seen plenty who sleep on a medium-firm mattress.
Combo sleepers Sleepers who alternate between the different sleeping positions often benefit from a medium-soft to a medium-firm bed, while avoiding overly plush or firm mattresses. They still need support and pressure relief, so somewhere in the middle of the firmness scale is ideal. How firm or soft within that scale will vary from person to person. Here are our selections for the best mattress for combo sleepers.
The Best Innerspring Mattress Brands
There are a lot of innerspring mattress brands out there—literally dozens. In fact, the innerspring mattress might the most common type of mattress. As such, it’s understandable that you’d want to know which mattress brand is the best. Here’s a list of some of the best innerspring mattress brands:
- Bear Mattress
- Brooklyn Bedding
- Helix Sleep
- Nest Bedding
- Purple Mattress
To be fair, there are about 10 other innerspring mattress brands that we really like, but we tried to keep things short and sweet for you. Our gut tells us that you’ll be just fine with at least one of the innerspring mattress brands listed above.
How Long Does A Hybrid Mattress Last?
All mattresses wear out over time and with use. However, there are things you can do at home to help prolong the life of your mattress while preserving its support and comfort. A typical life expectancy for both innerspring and hybrid mattresses is around ten years to 12 years max.
While that ten-year expectation often refers specifically to the springs in either mattress type, the upper layers on hybrid mattresses are usually designed to have a similar lifespan. Even so, some recommend estimating hybrid mattresses’ lifespans as closer to 8-10 years, as the foam material can wear out before the springs.
Practically speaking, a hybrid mattress is usually a coil mattress. In other words, most people consider a “hybrid” another term for “innerspring” or “coil.”
Pocket coils are essentially the same thing as innersprings, though traditional innersprings have the perimeter rail. Also, pocket coils are individually siloed and therefore can tend to isolate motion better.
They definitely can be. We are big fans of many hybrid mattresses, though, we should point out that comfort is subjective.
You would think so, but actually they can be quite affordable. We have tested and reviewed dozens of hybrid/coil mattresses that sell for under $1,500.
They can be, but they don’t have to be. You can find hybrid/coil/innerspring mattresses in all firmness levels, ranging from ultra plush to extra firm.