|AT A GLANCE||PRICING||HEADLINE|
|For Everyone||Extra 10% Off|
|10" thick mattress that has a neutral, soft foam feel and a moderate price tag. We think almost everyone will find this mattress comfortable.|
|Durable||Check Current Price||Hybrid bed that is cheap and will be more durable over the long haul, thanks to the coils in the mattress.|
|Ultra Cheap||Check Current Price||If price is your main concern, this soft memory foam mattress is a great option. It's best for side sleepers, but most people should be just fine on this bed.|
|Washable Cover||20% Off|
Discount in Cart
|A comfortable, soft foam bed that sports an affordable price tag and a machine washable cover.|
|Kids' Rooms||Check Current Price||8" thick all-foam mattress that is great for kids and teenagers. It's soft, comfortable, and finds a nice balance between support and pressure relief.|
|Popular Pick||Check Current Price||A popular pick among consumers. Tuft & Needle is an accommodating mattress that is good for pretty much all sleeper types.|
Number of Contributors
Choosing a bed for a rental property or AirBNB space can be a challenge because you want to make sure that it will be comfortable for a wide range of sleepers. And that’s not the only thing to think about. We’ll break it down for you.
Accommodating: An AirBNB bed is going to be the crash zone for all sorts of people. That means you need a mattress that’s going to be reasonably comfortable for all those sorts of people. An accommodating mattress will be somewhere in the middle of the firmness scale, but leaning towards firmer. Medium-firm is probably a good option because it caters to the largest range of body weights.
How much a person weighs affects how a mattress feels. Generally, the heavier a person is, the softer the bed feels. So when you’re choosing a mattress for various guests, it needs to be firm enough for heavier people to still feel supported. Lighter people can generally be comfortable on a wider range of firmness levels, so we cater to the heavier individuals in this case.
Sleeper Types: You’ll have some guests that are back sleepers and stomach sleepers, you’ll have guests that are side sleepers, and you’ll have some that are combo sleepers. Unfortunately, there isn’t one type of bed that will be perfect for all of them. However, you can find a pretty good middle-ground.
Back and stomach sleepers need a firmer bed that offers enough support around the hips and trunk area. Side sleepers need a softer bed that offers enough pressure relief to keep the spine in proper alignment. Combo sleepers need something in the middle.
So, keeping everyone in mind, again, a Medium-firm mattress is going to fall into the middle of the road. It will probably be a little firm for some side sleepers, but they’ll be fine for the few-night stay.
Reasonable Pricing: Mattresses can get pretty pricey. We all know that. And in some cases, it’s worth paying more for the right bed. When you’re looking for a bed that you’re going to sleep on for the next 10 years, give or take, it’s probably worth it. But when you’re looking for a bed that an ever-changing stream of guests are going to sleep on for a few nights at a time, it’s really not.
We think it’s perfectly reasonable to keep the cost below $1,000 for a queen size mattress. You don’t need to splurge on a fancy, luxury mattress that gets used by a wide variety of people because mattresses that come with big price tags are usually expensive due to their specific details that are intended to cater to one specific person or couple.
Before we begin talking about each individual mattress, let’s just quickly cover some housekeeping items. All of these mattresses ship for free and will arrive compressed in a box. The unboxing process is fairly straightforward and shouldn’t take more than 10-15 minutes. However, you should give the bed 24-48 hours to fully inflate before using.
Once you’ve got the mattress all set up, the typical bed-in-a-box company gives you 100 nights to test out the bed. Some give you additional time (Tulo gives you 120 nights) and some less. For example, if you’re buying an Amazon mattress, you’ll be operating within Amazon’s policies. That means you’ll basically get 30 nights to test out the bed (Amazon’s return policy).
If at any time during the trial period you decide the mattress you purchased isn’t for you, just give the company a call and they will send someone to your house to pick up the mattress free of charge and issue you a full refund (usually 8-10 days after the fact). Just a word of warning, we have heard Amazon is a little more stringent when it comes to returns. Most online mattress companies also back their products with a strong warranty. The typical warranty most bed-in-a-box companies offer is 10 years. If you want to see the best mattresses deals, click here.
With that said, let’s get into the individual beds.
We selected the Tulo mattress for this list for three primary reasons—it’s affordable, it’s available in three different firmness levels, and it has a neutral, soft foam feel that the majority of people will like. Let’s start with the first reason, which is pretty straight forward—it’s cheap. And let’s face it, when you’re trying to fill out a spare bedroom for a vacation rental, that’s often most important. A lot of times, Tulo will run sales where you can get a queen size mattress for the price of a twin.
We also like that the Tulo mattress is available in three different firmness levels—Soft, Medium, and Firm. We’d recommend going with the Medium version since it will accommodate all kinds of sleepers. However, you might also think about going with the Firm model since all-foam mattresses do soften over time. This might mean that the Firm version will soften to more of a medium type feel over time, extending the useful life of the mattress.
Lastly, we like that the Tulo mattress has a neutral, soft foam feel. It’s hard to guess what type of mattress material your guests will like since everyone has different preferences, so going with a neutral foam is a safe choice. Some people don’t like the feel of straight memory foam and others dislike the feel of innerspring beds.
Technically, Tulo uses a cooling memory foam layer on top, but it doesn’t feel like your typical memory foam. It’s slightly firmer and a little more responsive. Because of this, we think the vast majority of sleepers out there will like the Tulo mattress.
We are big fans of this mattress. Honestly, given its price point, it’s hard to find many negatives. If I personally was trying to fill out a vacation property, I’d pick this mattress for two reasons. One, it’s extremely affordable. The second reason is durability. This might sound a little insensitive, but I’d be more concerned about how long the mattress will last rather than how comfortable guests (who I don’t know) will find it. We’re just being practical here. And this mattress will be the most durable on this list.
It uses pocketed coils as opposed to dense foam for its support structure. In general, coils are more durable over the long haul than foam and also provide more support for heavy folks. But don’t get me wrong, this mattress is also decently comfortable.
Lucid feels more like a mix between neutral foam and memory foam, even though its title has memory foam in it. Bottom line, if you’re like me and you’re primarily concerned with price and durability, this bed in a box is a great choice.
Taking the best budget (our ultra cheap) selection is the 12″ Green Tea Memory Foam Mattress from Zinus. If price is your chief concern (i.e. you don’t care about body types, sleeper types, or anything like that), this mattress is the clear winner. It’s extremely cheap. You can often find a queen size mattress on Amazon well below the $200 mark.
There are a few more positives about this bed beyond just price, though. It’s a great option for people that really like that soft memory foam feel where you sort of sink in and the mattress hugs you. If that’s you, this bed is a great. It’s also a great option for side sleepers since it provides a ton of pressure relief for your hips and shoulders.
On the downside, it’s on the softer side of spectrum, so we’re not convinced back and stomach sleepers (especially heavier folks) will receive the proper support. Also, since the mattress does sort of hug you and its top layer is comprised of a thick layer of memory foam, this bed will sleep on the warm side, which is bad news for people that heat up at night. Regardless, it’s hard to argue with the price of this bed.
If you watched the video above, you probably noticed Eve mattress was one of our picks, but as of August 2018, the company is no longer selling their mattress in certain markets. Don’t worry, though, we have a worthy replacement for you.
A big reason why we included Eve in the original list was that it was soft, accommodating, and included a washable cover. Well, YogaBed fits that bill, as well.
YogaBed has a soft, neutral-foam feel (similar to Tulo) that is best for back, stomach, and combo sleepers. Like Eve, it also has a machine washable cover, which is pretty rare in the bed-in-box-industry. A machine washable cover is a big plus for rental properties. It’s just very convenient to be able to pop off the cover and throw it in the wash instead of spot cleaning it.
Plus, YogaBed sports a pretty affordable price tag.
A lot of vacation rental properties have rooms specifically designed for kids and teens, whether it’s in the form of bunk beds or child-themed murals or posters on the wall. As such, we thought it was worth having a specific pick for these types of rooms. And that’s the Essential model from Casper.
This mattress provides a nice blend of pressure relief and support for petite and medium sized people. At only 8.5″ thick, though, we just don’t think this mattress is the best choice for large sized adults. Still, we think it’s ideal for all kinds of sleepers. Doesn’t matter whether you’re on your back, side, or stomach.
The Essential also has a nice neutral, soft foam feel that most children and teens will love. What’s also nice about this mattress is that it has a charcoal-colored cover. As such, any stains or accidents children have will be easily hidden.
We just couldn’t leave this mattress off the list. It’s pretty much known as THE “Budget Bed In A Box” on the market. Last we checked, it had a 4.5 star rating on Amazon with over 6,500 reviews. It was also featured as Consumer Reports’ “Best Value Pick” a couple years back. And we can see why—the Tuft & Needle mattress checks a lot of boxes. It’s affordable, accommodates most sleeper types, and is a great choice for partners who share a mattress.
If you’re trying to furnish your vacation rental, but you’re not interested in doing too much research, you just want to buy a mattress from trusted brand that you know is comfortable and performs well in almost all categories, it’s hard to argue with Tuft & Needle.
The Slumber Yard knows mattresses. It’s what we do. It’s our business. We’ve tested literal stacks of mattresses, and we’re also very familiar with the online mattress shopping industry. We can do some good in the way of steering you in the right direction.
Our team isn’t a group of sleep scientists or mattress company big-wigs. We’re made up of a bunch of normal people who value a good night’s sleep, just like you. We vary in height, body type, sleeper type, gender, etc., so we cover a decently diverse sleep experience. And our opinions are always 100% our own. We have complete control over our content and our number one goal is to provide helpful information.
Mattress construction has two basic categories (plus gel, but that’s far less common). There are all-foam beds and hybrid beds. All-foam beds are exactly what you think they are—all foam. They vary in number of layers and types of foam used, which means despite them all being all-foam, they still come in different feels and levels of firmness. Hybrid beds incorporate foam, coils, and some other material. Again, the layers and materials vary from bed to bed. They usually have a more bouncy feel that’s similar to the traditional innerspring feel a lot of people are used to. Mattress materials come in a wide range of feels, firmness levels, and functions. When you go to choose a mattress, it’s a good idea to look into what kind of materials are incorporated. Paying attention to the materials gives you a good idea of how the bed will feel and how long it will last.
Memory Foam — Memory foam is a denser foam that softens over time and when heat is applied. You’ll get that sink-in feeling if you lay in one spot. For some people, this feels like being comfortably cradled, but for others it’s like being stuck. See the best memory foam mattresses.
Polyurethane Foam — Poly foam is generally used for support in all-foam mattresses because it’s affordable and comes in many different densities. With any foam, the denser it is, the firmer it feels. It’s somewhat cooler than memory foam, but this depends on the density, as well. It generally has a lower point elasticity than memory foam, so when you press in on one area, it affects a larger area.
Gel Memory Foam — Gel memory foam is a newer technology that incorporates gel into the foam to help improve temperature regulation. It’s intended to help cool people down. It’s not a perfect solution, though, because the bed can still warm up a bit.
Latex Foam — Latex foam is a spongy feeling material. It’s very bouncy and airy and stays cooler than memory foam. See our favorite latex mattresses.
Pocketed Coils — Pocketed coils are individually encased coils that are woven together with the fabric. They allow for really good airflow, support, bounce, and responsiveness. They’re also fairly good in terms of motion transfer control since the coils are individual. You get much more precise support with pocketed coils than with non-pocketed coils.
Innersprings — Innersprings are more than likely what you remember from your 10-year-old mattress. These are larger coils all connected together. This is the traditional system. They’re great for airflow, bounce, and support, but terrible with motion transfer since the whole system sort of moves as one. In other words, very low point elasticity.
Gel/Hyper Elastic Polymer — This material is heavy and has its own unique feel that’s unlike any other material. It has great airflow, responsiveness, pressure relief, and support. It also tends to have high point elasticity (i.e. press in on one area and it doesn’t spread too much to the other side of the mattress), which makes for low cross-bed motion.
Once you’ve gone through the trouble (and money) of buying your new mattress, you want to make sure it lives a long and useful life. Your first step is checking out the company’s information on how often or if you should be rotating or flipping your bed. You should also check out the cleaning instructions. Most mattresses have non-removable covers, which means you can’t just toss them in a washing machine. Even when the cover is removable, it’s rarely machine washable. In that case, you’ll need to spot clean if you have a spill or a stain to manage. Spot cleaning, while maybe not the most convenient or thorough, is pretty easy. You just need warm water with a little detergent. Use a washcloth to dab at the stain. If it’s a wet stain, use a dry towel to soak up as much liquid as you can before spot cleaning.