|AT A GLANCE||PRICING||HEADLINE|
Soft Foam Mattress
|The Bowery tips the budget a bit (it technically belongs on the best under 600 list), but it’s a comfortable, quality bed —especially for the price.|
|See on Amazon||If you're looking for a flippable mattress—and price is a major factor in your decision making process—the Nest Flip mattress is unmatched. It's affordable, comfortable, and a heck of a bed overall.|
|It's hard to believe this mattress is offered at such an affordable price. Not only does the bed have a high-quality construction but it also comfortably accommodates back, stomach and combo sleepers.|
|See on Amazon||One of the most cost-effective foam beds you can buy online, period. The mattress comes in multiple thickness options and accommodates all types of sleepers.|
Memory Foam Hybrid
|See on Amazon||Another inexpensive hybrid mattress that combines pocketed coils and layers of memory foam. The bed comfortably accommodates a variety of sleeper types and body types.|
Number of Contributors
Now, we know this is a best under 500 list, but we did sneak in a one option that is just above this price threshold. Technically, it should be considered “best under 600” but with discounts, it lands closer to 500 and we really do think it’s worth your consideration, so we included it anyway. Also, if you’re not totally sold on a new bed, we’ve posted an article about the best mattress toppers for your reference.
But don’t worry—we also have four other beds on this list that are priced well under that $500 mark. Some of these beds are sold exclusively on Amazon, which is fine but keep in mind that when you buy from Amazon as opposed to buying directly from the brand’s website, the policies won’t always adhere to online mattress industry standards. Just make sure to check the product page for details and terms regarding shipping, returns, trial periods, and warranties.
The Brooklyn Bowery pushes the budget a bit (it’s just over $500 with discounts) but it’s a great mattress for the price you pay. Make sure to check the discount box on the right to see what the company is currently offering.
The Bowery has a soft neutral-foam feel and will work for all sleeper types, though we’d say it’s slightly preferable for side sleepers. It isn’t a very thick mattress and it doesn’t have coils, so we don’t suggest it for heavier folks but it’s still quite comfortable nevertheless.
Ultimately, the Bowery is a solid mattress, especially considering its price point. We think of the Bowery as a more affordable, slightly softer Casper mattress. It’s from a well known brand (Brooklyn Bedding) and it truly is a very nice bed for just over $500 (queen size).
The Nest Bedding Flip is a budget-tier mattress that you can get on Amazon for around $400 for the queen size. Usually, with a flippable mattress, you’re looking at $1,000 out-the-door, especially if that bed has coils. Nest Flip has coils and is really comfortable—and yet is still highly affordable.
This particular bed comes in around a medium on the firmness scale for the “Medium” side and a medium-firm to firm on the “Firm” side. The bed also has 6″ coils for added support and durability. As a result, all sleeper types and just about any body type should be fine on this mattress.
Bottom line, the Nest Bedding Flip is a solid option if you’re interested in a flippable mattress, but are working with a tight budget. While it’s a little more expensive, often times, than Allswell, we can’t help but think that it’s a tremendous value.
If you’re on a tight budget and just want a durable, accommodating bed, look no further than the Allswell Hybrid mattress. It’s no doubt one of the best mattresses for the money you can buy online.
The Allswell Hybrid is actually manufactured by Brooklyn Bedding, which is a well-respected US-based mattress company. As such, the bed has a high-quality construction that mixes pocketed coils, poly foam and a quilted memory foam cover.
However, despite the top layer of memory foam, we’d say the bed has more of a neutral-foam feel overall. In other words, the top layers don’t quite conform to your body as much as the top layers on more traditional memory foam beds.
Still, we found the bed to be very comfortable. Given it lands in-between a medium and medium-firm on the firmness scale, we think the bed is best for back, stomach and combo sleepers. It might just be a little too firm for people who spend the majority of the night sleeping on their side.
At the end of the day, it’s difficult to find many negatives with this bed. It’s just solid in almost every respect. And let’s forget that it’s insanely affordable. You can often snag a queen size for around $300. That’s crazy town considering all you get with this bed.
As they have in other industries, Amazon has figured out a way to produce their own bed and undercut the competition. However, don’t let the extremely low price fool you, the AmazonBasics memory foam bed-in-a-box is actually quite comfortable.
Despite its title, the bed really only uses a thin layer of memory foam. As such, the mattress has more of generic, soft foam feel overall that is very accommodating. We think the bed lands around a medium on the firmness scale and will work for all types of sleepers (side, back and stomach).
However, because it is a budget all-foam bed, we wouldn’t recommend it for people who weigh more than 250 pounds. If you fall into that category, you’d be better off with one of the hybrid beds on this list that provide more support.
Still, if price is your main concern, I don’t know if you’ll find a cheaper, more accommodating mattress. You can often find a 10″ queen size for under $250. It might not last you ten years but it will definitely get the job done for awhile.
Like the Allswell Hybrid, the Lucid Hybrid mattress combines memory foam, poly foam, and pocketed coils, and it’s priced well under $500. You can typically find this bed on Amazon for around $320-$250 (queen size), though prices do fluctuate.
This Lucid mattress looks surprisingly good—a nice reminder that cheap doesn’t have to mean cheap-looking. This is a pretty accommodating mattress in that it’ll work for all sleeper types and all body types. You get a nice balance of pressure relief and support thanks to the foam layers and coils, respectively.
Overall, we think the Lucid 10” memory foam hybrid is a good buy for the price and we think it will be fairly durable because of the coils.
Here at the Slumber Yard, we aim to provide consumers with helpful, accurate, and unbiased information. The online mattress shopping industry can be an intimidating place, overflowing with buzzwords, marketing tactics, and seemingly endless choices. We’ve done our best to take the guesswork out of buying a mattress online without the opportunity to feel it for yourself.
You can trust the Slumber Yard to give you real commentary on each product we review. Regardless of how we get our hands on a product—whether we paid for it or received it for free—we have full control of our content and all opinions are 100% our own. We will never over- or undersell a bed. That’s not the point of what we do here. It’s not our goal to sell you a mattress; it’s our goal to help you find the right mattress.
When we get a new mattress (a bed-in-a-box mattress or otherwise), we put it through a litany of tests. We evaluate its feel, firmness, responsiveness, motion isolation, edge support, and a handful of other features. Our Slumber Yard team is comprised of diverse body types and all sleeper types, which allows us to consider each bed from various perspectives.
We talk about weight and body type all the time in our reviews because comfort is so affected by a person’s build. Different bodies require different things, just as different people have different preferences. Heavier folks, for example, will generally experience a bed to be softer than rated, while someone who’s quite petite will think the bed is firmer than rated. In our content, we do our best to account for all body types and let you know how a mattress will feel for petite, average, and heavier folks. It’s a simple concept, but it’s also an easy one to overlook when you start reading up on a mattress. That’s why we make an effort to remind you to keep your own body in mind while considering a bed.
“Sleeper type” refers to the position you sleep in—back, stomach, side, or a combination of those. We reference sleeper type in our content because how you sleep plays a role in determining what kind of mattress is best for you.
We like to break down our reasoning in each mattress review, mattress comparison, and best list, but here’s a quick explanation of what we mean when we say a bed is good or bad for a certain sleeper type: In all cases, it’s important to keep your spine in proper alignment while you sleep. For back sleepers and stomach sleepers, that means supporting your hips and trunk area to prevent uncomfortable sinkage. For side sleepers, that means allowing pressure relief around the shoulder and hip areas to prevent uncomfortable gapping under the stomach or compression in the torso.
Mattresses aren’t cheap and we all know this, but that doesn’t mean you have to go into debt to avoid sleeping on the ground.
How much you spend on a mattress is really up to you. Sure, there’s an established price range, but it’s a wide range. We’ve tried $200 mattresses, but we’ve also tried $2,000 mattresses. And, truthfully, you’ll find beds that stretch it even farther.
Where in that spending range you find yourself is a personal decision. You’ll have to consider your financial situation, as well as what features of a mattress are important to you. It’s a balance. We will say, though, that spending more doesn’t necessarily mean you’ll get a better bed for you. So don’t splurge on a mattress thinking that the extravagant price tag will buy you a better night’s sleep.
Amazon has just about anything you could think to buy, including mattresses. And generally speaking, purchasing a mattress on Amazon can save you a decent amount of money.
A few things to note if you go the Amazon route, though, are the return, trial period, and warranty policies. Online mattress industry standard is to offer free shipping, free returns with full refunds, a 100-night trial period, and 10-year warranties. Amazon, however, is under no obligation to uphold those standards and rarely do. They still offer those things, just on their own terms. So be sure to read up on how they handle returns, trials, and warranties before you click “Place Order.” You can usually find that information on the product page.
Something else to think about when considering an Amazon mattress purchase is how long you want your new bed to last. When do you plan on replacing it? I know, it seems silly to think about when you’re going to replace a mattress you haven’t even bought yet, but it matters because Amazon beds aren’t usually the ones that are built to last you 15+ years. I’m thinking of brands like Lucid, Linenspa, and Zinus, for example, which are great beds for guest rooms, teenagers, college apartments, or the interim between moving out of your parents’ place and moving in with a partner. But if you want a bed that’s going to last a good, long time, it’s probably worth spending a bit more and investing in a better-made mattress through a company that offers longer, more inclusive warranties and the like.
We don’t think there’s a “best time,” per se, because when you need a new bed, you need a new bed. As far as timing for the best deals, if you have the option of waiting for a major holiday, you can usually cash in on the sales that pop up around those times of year. You can also find good deals on cyber and shopping event days, like Black Friday, Cyber Monday, and Prime Day.
If your situation is dire, though, and you can’t put off your purchase, that’s okay—there are many, many companies that toss out coupons and promo codes year-round. It’s just a matter of knowing where to look (like the Slumber Yard!). Be sure to check out our Mattress Deals page to see the best discounts companies are currently offering.