Allswell is fast becoming one of the best online mattress brands, while Puffy has been a household name for years. In this comparison we focus on the flagship mattress from both companies. Our goal is to help you find which mattress of the two is right for you. Perhaps you'll prefer the Allswell Hybrid because of its coils or the soft foam feel of Puffy.

$265 – $465Price Range$795 – $1,350
20% Off Code: RIZSLUMBER20Offer $300 Off + Gift Discount In Cart
  • Budget shoppers
  • If you want an innerspring mattress
Best For
  • Shoppers seeking a comfortable, affordable foam mattress
  • All types of sleepers, including back, stomach and side
100 NightsTrial Period101 Nights
10 yearsWarrantyLifetime
Free Shipping and ReturnsShipping Options Free Shipping and Returns
Shop Now Shop Now

While Allswell and Puffy don’t have a whole heck of a lot in common, here’s a quick list of the policy items associated with both mattresses:

  • Free Shipping — Both are bed-in-a-box mattress brands that will not charge you extra for shipping.
  • Trial Windows — Puffy allows you to try their mattress for 101 nights, and Allswell, 100 nights.
  • Free Returns — If you decide you want a refund for Allswell or Puffy during the trial period, both brands offer completely free returns.

Aside from that, you do get a warranty with Puffy and Allswell. For instance, Puffy comes with a lifetime warranty, while Allswell has a standard 10-year warranty. For more information on the beds, check out the sections below.

Why You Should Get Allswell — We have no shortage of positive comments about “The Allswell” or the brand at large. In this section we will discuss why Allswell might be preferable for you over Puffy.

allswell mattress review hybrid bed for heavy people walmart
Here’s a look at “The Allswell” mattress (the entry level product from the brand)

Allswell Is A Budget Mattress — We consider both of these beds to be affordable, however, Allswell is notably cheaper than Puffy. If your budget is around $500, Allswell is the clear winner.

We often say that price should be a factor when you’re mattress shopping, but it shouldn’t be the factor. That point is especially true with the Allswell vs Puffy debate. As much as we like “The Allswell” and think it’s a tremendous value mattress, you need to make sure it’s what you want in terms of feel and firmness before you take the plunge.

Even so, Allswell is a seriously affordable bed with an MSRP of around $400 for the queen size bed. As if that wasn’t enough, Allswell Home isn’t opposed to offering discounts and sales. You can visit Allswell’s website for their current discounts if there are any. Usually during major holidays you’ll see some sort of sale.

As for Puffy, it’s a low-priced mattress as well—the queen has an MSRP of around $1,150. The brand is also no stranger to promotions. Almost always, Puffy is running a sale on their website in the range of around $300.

allswell hybrid mattress review stomach sleeper
Allswell is in the M to MF range

Firmness Ratings — Allswell is firmer than Puffy. We consider Puffy to be a medium, while Allswell is between a medium and medium-firm.

As a result, we would argue that Allswell is preferable for individuals that tend to favor their stomach or back while sleeping. Puffy is fine for all sleeping positions—including back and stomach—but Allswell is just firmer.

Hybrid Mattress — Puffy makes two mattresses, both of which are entirely foam. Allswell, on the other hand, makes three coil mattresses, which will be more optimal for heavy people.

It’s not even controversial to say that obese and large people should try a coil mattress first. The fact of the matter is if you’re over ~230 lbs, you will likely prefer Allswell over the long run.

Why Puffy Is The Better Mattress — As nice is the Allswell mattress is, there’s a large cohort of people that will simply prefer Puffy. Here are the major reasons why Puffy is a darn good mattress, and might be better for you than Allswell.

puffy mattress review bed in a box
This is the standard Puffy mattress (they also offer “Puffy Lux”)

Easy Pick — In many of our best mattress lists we talk of Puffy as the “Easy Pick” or “Safe Pick.” Nothing could be more true. This is just a comfortable mattress that the overwhelming majority of people will find pleasant.

Puffy has what we call a soft foam feel, meaning it feels like a big slab of softer, neutral foam. It does have memory foam as its main comfort layer, however, there’s not an overtly memory foam feel.

If you took a group of 100 people, our bet would be that more people prefer the overall feel of Puffy than Allswell. It just offers a little more cushioning than the original Allswell mattress. Having said that, remember that both brands offer other beds with different firmness levels.

Puffy mattress side sleeper review
We can’t imagine many people will dislike Puffy

Puffy Has A Medium Firmness — While Allswell is a medium-firm, as we mentioned, Puffy is closer to a true medium. As a result, it’s a more natural fit for side sleepers, at least in comparison to Allswell.

Most of the mail order mattresses that we’ve reviewed have a medium firmness just like Puffy. It’s really popular because it allows the bed to work for all sleeping positions.

Washable Cover — Part of the reason that Puffy made our Best RV Mattress list is that it has a washable cover. Most beds, online or otherwise, do not have a machine-washable cover. This allows you to deep clean the mattress, making it a great fit for kids, teens, seniors, vacation property owners, and more.

Review team

  • kenzie
    McKenzie Dillon

    Combo Sleeper

  • dillon lopez slumber yard
    Dillon Lopez

    Combo Sleeper

  • reynoso
    Jack Reynoso

    Combo Sleeper

  • Owen Poole

    Side Sleeper