We are supported by readers purchasing through our links. This page may contain products from our partners. Learn more
AmazonBasics vs Casper Mattress

AmazonBasics vs Casper Mattress

Can the Amazon Basics mattress actually compete with most popular bed in a box, Casper?

Last Updated: September 30, 2020

Casper was one of the early pioneers of the mattress-in-a-box concept, while Amazon operates the most prominent online marketplace in the world. Despite the differences between the two businesses, both companies offer extremely popular beds. In this post, we compare and contrast the Original Casper and AmazonBasics mattresses.

AT A GLANCEPRICINGHEADLINE
AmazonBasics Memory Foam Mattress Memory Foam See On Amazon Applied in CartThe AmazonBasics memory foam mattress is cheap, but surprisingly comfortable. If price is your main concern, it’s hard to find a more affordable bed than this one.
Casper Original Soft Foam $100 Off Code: SLUMBERYARDCasper Original is the mattress that started it all. If you just want a comfortable foam mattress, it’s hard to do better than Casper.

AmazonBasics vs Casper Mattress Overview

We understand not everyone loves reading about mattresses, so to speed things up, here are the primary points of differentiation between these two beds.

  • Price — The AmazonBasics mattress is much more affordable than the Original Casper.
  • Construction — Both beds have a somewhat simple construction, but the Casper mattress incorporates a special “Zoned Support” layer for added comfort and support. Casper also released two hybrid models (coils and foam).
  • Trial Period/Warranty — Casper offers a much longer trial period and warranty.

Those are the primary differences between the beds. As you will learn in the coming sections, the AmazonBasics and Casper mattresses actually have a lot in common. The first portion of this post will focus on the differences between the two beds (surprisingly, there aren’t that many), and then near the end, we’ll summarize the areas in which they overlap. As you will read below, the mattresses are actually quite similar in terms of feel, firmness, and temperature regulation. Now, let’s get to it already.

Jump-To Links For This Comparison

AmazonBasics Vs Casper Mattress Review Video

AmazonBasics Mattress Review

Though AmazonBasics is newer to the bed-in-a-box competition, they offer a solid alternative to the Casper mattress. Amazon’s model has the major advantage of offering a similar product at a lower price point.

AmazonBasics Mattress Construction & Design

One advantage the AmazonBasics mattress has over Casper is flexibility. The mattress is available in three different heights (a.k.a. thickness). You can choose between 8″, 10″, and 12″ options. Keep in mind that as you increase the thickness, the price increases, as well. Don’t worry, though, the bed’s construction largely stays the same regardless of the option you choose. Each model is comprised of three foam layers, only the thickness of the different layers changes.

amazon basics edge support
A closer look at the 8″ model, which is a great option for kids

The AmazonBasics mattress consists of three foam layers and doesn’t really have any standout features or technology built in. Overall, it’s just a very basic construction.

It’s nice that the bed comes in various options. We think each model is best suited for a particular group of people and situations. For example, we think the 8″ model is an excellent choice for filling out kids’ rooms or for outfitting your camping trailer. The 10″ model is great for teenagers and young adults in college, and the 12″ model is for people who want a thicker, more durable bed (comparatively speaking).

SEE ALSO: AmazonBasics vs Tuft & Needle Mattress Comparison

Casper Mattress Review

Casper is one of the original bed-in-a-box companies. As a result, they’ve got an excellent product to offer. Depending on the amount of money you have to spend on your next mattress, you might find the more advanced construction and design, along with the longer trial period and warranty, worth the extra money.

Casper Mattress Construction & Design

The Original Casper mattress is an all-foam bed-in-a-box that consists of three foam layers and totals about 11″ thick. Most notably, the bed incorporates a special layer that Casper calls its “Zoned Support Foam.” What’s cool about this layer is that it’s actually split into thirds. The top and bottom portions are slightly softer to provide more pressure relief for your shoulders and legs and the middle portion is slightly firmer to provide more support under your lower back and hips. In addition, the Original Casper mattress is manufactured in the USA. I know that’s a big deal for some consumers who insist on buying American made products.

casper original mattress review zoned support
An up-close look at one side of the Zoned Support System

IMPORTANT UPDATE: Casper has two hybrid mattresses called Casper Wave Hybrid and Casper Nova Hybrid. They have similar constructions to the original Casper mattress which we’re discussing here. Differences in the hybrid mattresses include:

  • Pocketed coil base to provide a solid and supportive mattress base, suitable for all sleeper types
  • Casper Nova has a softer profile than the Casper Wave bed
  • They both offer additional zoned support for even more pressure relief and support.

Differences Between AmazonBasics And Casper

We already touched on this above, but it’s worth mentioning again. The Casper mattress comes with a 100-night risk-free trial period and a 10-year warranty. If you were sleep reading above (get it?) or you just missed it, the AmazonBasics mattress does not come with an official trial period. Also, the mattress is only backed by a one-year warranty. Out of all the mattresses we’ve reviewed, it’s only the bed with a warranty shorter than 10 years.

casper mattress review original edge support
Extra 70 nights to test the Casper mattress

You might be asking why this is important? Well, it normally takes around 30-45 days for your body to adjust to a new bed and for the bed to properly break in. Given this, the extra 70 nights that Casper allows you test the bed is suddenly more relevant. If you buy the AmazonBasics mattress and like it at first, but then after day 30 it starts to break in too much for your liking, you’re out of luck.

Also, it doesn’t inspire much confidence that Amazon only backs their mattress with a one-year warranty. To play devil’s advocate, though, you could buy a new AmazonBasics bed every couple years and still come out ahead in terms of money spent compared to buying one Casper mattress.

Similarities Between Casper and AmazonBasics

Above, we described how these two beds differ, but now it’s time to discuss their commonalities. Spoiler alert—they have a quite a few similarities. All in all, this was one of the more difficult comparisons for us to complete.

Feel And Firmness

Both of these mattresses use memory foam in their construction. The AmazonBasics mattress uses it for its top layer, while the Casper mattress uses it for its secondary comfort layer. However, before you automatically classify both as “memory foam beds,” we actually wouldn’t say the mattresses have a traditional memory foam feel. Yes, you do get a slight memory foam sensation in which the top layers sort of wrap or hug your body, but it’s not overwhelming at all.

amazon basics side sleeper mattress
Soft, neutral-foam feel with a bit of memory foam sprinkled in

Overall, we’d say both beds have more of a generic, soft foam feel. The top layers simply do not contour or conform to your body as much as, say, the top layers on the Nectar mattress. Ultimately, the best way we can describe the feel of both mattresses is that they have a soft, neutral-foam feel with a hint of memory foam. If you want a bed with more of a traditional memory foam feel, be sure to check out our list of the Best Memory Foam Mattresses.

Besides feel, the mattresses are also similar in terms of firmness. We think both beds land around a medium on the firmness scale. Both mattresses find a pretty nice balance between support and pressure relief.

CASPER MATTRESS REVIEW FIRMNESS AND FEEL OF THIS BED

Sleeper Style

As such, we think all types of sleepers will be just fine on these beds. Whether you primarily sleep on your side, back, or stomach, you’ll find both mattresses to be very accommodating. Plus, another nice thing is that both mattresses are fairly responsive. This means the top layers pop back to position quickly after pressure is released and you won’t get any sort of that stuck-in-the-mud type feel that is common with beds that contain memory foam.

SEE ALSO: Best Mattress for Side Sleepers

Generally speaking, the level of responsiveness shown above is a good sign for combination sleepers. People who rotate between positions frequently find it much easier to switch between positions on beds that have top layers that respond quickly.

Will These Mattresses Work For Heavy People?

Given the basic, all-foam construction of each bed, we don’t think the Original Casper and AmazonBasics mattresses are ideal for people who weigh more than 250 lb. Large individuals exert more force onto a mattress than petite and medium sized individuals and require beds that have a solid support framework.

Given this, we almost always recommend heavy folks go with a bed that contains coils instead. Coils (or innerspring units) provide more support than the dense poly foams that all-foam beds (like Casper and AmazonBasics) use for the foundations. In addition, coils have proven to be more durable over the long haul, as well.

If you’re reading this and you consider yourself a large individual, you should check out the new Casper Hybrid or Wave Hybrid. If these don’t tickle your fancy, take a look at our list of the Best Hybrid & Coil Mattresses. If you weigh less than 250 lb, though, the AmazonBasics and Casper mattresses will suffice just fine.

AmazonBasics Vs Casper Mattress Pricing

This is the best part about the AmazonBasics mattresses. All three models are extremely affordable. In fact, they are among the cheapest beds you can buy online. Here’s how pricing compares to Casper based on a queen size mattress.

  • AmazonBasics 8″: $200
  • AmazonBasics 10″: $230
  • AmazonBasics 12″: $260
  • Original Casper: $1,000

As you can clearly see, Amazon wins this by a mile. AmazonBasics beds are about $800-$900 cheaper, depending on the model you choose. However, those are just the MSRP prices. Chances are you can snag each mattress listed above for less than the MSRP price.

Casper, like most bed-in-a-box companies, regularly offers coupon codes and promo codes. Typically, they offer around $50-$100 off, but around major holidays they’ll bump up the discount even more. You might want to keep an eye on Casper.com to see what the company is currently offering.
Amazon doesn’t regularly offer discount codes for its AmazonBasics mattress, but we have noticed that pricing seems to fluctuate, almost on a weekly basis. You might be able to snag one of the mattress models for $30-$50 less than MSRP if you keep an eye on current pricing on Amazon.

AmazonBasics Vs Casper Mattress Review Verdict

Congratulations, you made it to the end of this mattress-in-a-box comparison. Hopefully by now, you understand how these two beds differ and where they overlap in terms of similarities. In our opinion, the decision between the two beds really boils down to two main factors. Ask yourself the following.

First, what’s your budget? If every dollar matters, go with the AmazonBasics mattress. You’ll end up saving several hundred dollars.

Next, do you know what type of bed or feel you want? If you’re not really sure what exactly you want, try Casper first. Take advantage of the 100-night risk-free trial period and really figure out what you like/dislike.

Review team

  • Dillon Payne

    Combo Sleeper

  • kenzie
    McKenzie Dillon

    Combo Sleeper

  • reynoso
    Jack Reynoso

    Combo Sleeper

  • JD
    JD Christison

    Combo Sleeper

FAQs

Which mattress is best for back or stomach sleepers?

This is one of the areas where AmazonBasics and Casper are fairly competitive — both mattresses are very accommodating whether you sleep on your side, back, or stomach.

Which bed costs less money, Casper vs AmazonBasics?

The AmazonBasics mattress comes in at a significantly lower price point than the original Casper Mattress. You can snag a queen size any of the AmazonBasics models for less than $300. But the same size mattress from Casper will run you around $1,000. And if you opt for one of the hybrid models that Casper offers, the price only goes up.

What’s the main difference between the two?

There are three key differences between the AmazonBasics and Casper mattresses. AmazonBasics has the advantage of coming in at a much lower price point. But the Casper bed has more advanced construction and a much longer trial period and warranty. You’ll have to decide for yourself whether those additional perks are worth the extra money.