Casper Element vs Casper Original Mattress Comparison
In this guide we compare Casper Element and the Original Casper mattress.
Last Updated: December 4, 2020Jeff Rizzo
Our goal is to help you sort out the Casper Element vs Casper Original debate. Both are online mattresses that ship in a box, and both are, obviously, from the same brand. So what would cause you to purchase one over the other? It may seem unclear at this point, but as you go through our comparison, you'll find the answer and hopefully your next mattress.
Casper Original vs Casper Element Overview
If you’re familiar with the whole concept of bed in a box mattresses, it’s likely you know about Casper. They are partly responsible for bringing the craze into the mainstream, and have simplified the whole mattress shopping process to be way more painless. Casper offers several different mattresses from hybrid beds to all-foam, such as the topics of this comparison the original Casper and Casper Element.
These two beds are some of the most affordable offerings from the brand, and we think each Casper mattress has something different to offer consumers. Here is a breakdown of what you can expect to learn in this comparison between Casper Original vs Casper Element:
- Casper Original is more expensive than the Casper Element mattress.
- Casper Element has a 2-layer foam construction while the flagship Casper mattress has a 3-layer all-foam construction with a zoned support design.
- The Casper Element is just a hair firmer than the original Casper Mattress.
For help navigating our original Casper vs Casper Element review, use the links below to jump to any section you choose.
Casper Original Mattress Review
Let’s take a deep dive into the Casper Original, the brand’s extremely popular flagship mattress, to get a better idea of what kind of sleepers it suits best.
Original Mattress Construction And Materials
The top-rated Casper Mattress has a simple, yet accommodating 3-layer construction. Here are the layers starting from the top:
- Comfort layer – Breathable open-cell foam which feels like classic neutral-foam
- Transition layer – A responsive memory foam layer with zoned support to act as a transition in between the dense support foam, and soft top layer
- Base layer – Durable support foam meant to provide a solid foundation for the mattress
The Original Casper mattress also features a Zoned Support layer to offer targeted support and pressure relief. The concept here is that the center layer is slightly firmer to offer more support for the bulk of your body. At the top and bottom, however, you should get more pressure relief, mainly to prevent back pain and shoulder pain.
Casper Mattress Feel And Firmness
On our scale from soft to firm, we rated Casper right in the middle at a medium. A good way to describe it would be a good balance between supportive, and pressure relieving.
And although this mattress contains memory foam, we definitely don’t think it has a memory foam feel. Instead, it’s a neutral, classic feeling foam that’s lighter, more breathable, and more bouncy than traditional memory foam.
Casper Element Mattress Review
The Casper Element mattress is constructed a little differently than the Casper Original. Here’s how it’s made and who the Casper Element is best for.
Casper Element Construction And Materials
When comparing Casper Element vs. the original Casper, the Casper Element mattress has one less foam layer, and omits the zoned support layer. The Element has:
- Comfort layer – A top perforated AirScape foam layer for that signature Casper comfort
- Base layer – A bottom dense poly foam support layer to provide support
This makes the Element slightly thinner, but also more affordable.
Casper Element Mattress Feel And Firmness
The Casper Element is rated only a little bit firmer than the original Casper Mattress, a touch more than medium but not yet medium-firm. This won’t make a huge difference for sleepers, unless you’re more petite and prefer an extra plush mattress.
Although it’s a little firmer, Casper Element will also have that classic neutral-foam feel that made the original Casper Mattress so popular.
Casper Company Policies
- Trial period length: 100 nights
- Warranty policy: 10-year limited warranty
- Shipping info: Free shipping
Both mattresses have the same trial period, warranty and shipping, so you can try the mattresses risk-free and rest assured your investment is covered from defects for 10 years.
Casper Original vs. Casper Element Pricing
Casper’s entire product lineup is designed to offer a mattress at every price point. The Element is the entry-level bed meant for budget shoppers, and Casper serves more of the mass market. For example, the queen size Casper Element is around $595 compared to the original’s price of $1,095.
|Size||Casper Original Price||Casper Element Price|
Casper Mattress Sleeper Type Analysis
The Casper mattresses fare between medium and medium-firm, and they work best for petite to average body types. We also think they suit almost every sleeper position. However, there are a few exceptions that we’ll get into.
Petite to average side sleepers may want to choose the original Casper mattress because it’s a tad less firm, but if you switch from your side to your back or stomach, the Element model should work for you.
Petite side sleepers under ~140 lbs should definitely consider the original Casper, or an even softer mattress if you need that extra plush pressure relief.
Back And Stomach
We think most back and stomach sleepers will appreciate the balanced feel of Casper Original or Casper Element. Casper Element is a firmer bed, but Casper is thicker and still offers a nice balance between support and pressure relief.
Combination sleepers who aren’t too heavy in weight will find Casper mattresses to be very accommodating. They both have medium firmness profiles, and are responsive to pressure (unlike many memory foams), which makes it easier to switch positions during the night.
Petite To Average Individuals
All-foam mattresses like Casper Element vs Casper original are made to suit average to petite-sized individuals because they don’t offer the extra support that hybrid beds do, so either bed should be perfectly accommodating.
We think heavier sleepers should opt for a hybrid mattress like Casper Wave or Casper Nova because they offer more support and longer-lasting durability with their pocketed coil base layers. Casper Element and their flagship model probably won’t stand the test of time for heavy folks. Or, you can check out our list for the best beds for heavy sleepers if you want to look at a few value picks.
Casper Element vs. Original Mattress Review Verdict
We aren’t in the business of telling you what you should think or do. We endeavor to layout the case for each mattress and let you make up your own mind. Here’s what it all boils down to:
- Casper Original — Thicker, more popular, and includes the “Zoned Support” layer. Also comes in a hybrid version.
- Casper Element — More affordable, but still nice.
At the end of the day, both are accommodating beds that come with free shipping and returns. If you give one a try and don’t like it, send it back for a full refund.
Other Casper Models
As we mentioned earlier, Casper offers both hybrid and foam options. This post covered Casper’s basic foam beds, but we also want to touch on the Casper hybrid models as well just in case you want something more durable and supportive.
Casper Wave – Casper Wave is their newest and most expensive model from the brand. It’s five layers compared to the 3-layer construction of the original Casper Mattress, 13″ thick, and incorporates a layer of natural latex foam on top of the special zoned support layer.
Casper Nova – While this is one of the premium models from Casper, it’s a tad less expensive than Casper Wave. This bed is designed with an upgraded “Zoned Support Pro” system, and is actually the softest, most plush bed that the brand offers.
Other Casper Products
Why Trust Us
Get the kind of sleep you’ve only dreamed of with some help from our team of mattress experts. We personally test more than 150 of the best sleep solutions from over 60 leading brands on site, so you can be sure you’re getting unbiased reviews, fair comparisons and personalized recommendations.
If you’re on a budget, the Casper Element is less expensive. If you’d like zoned support or you’re a larger or heavier in size, the Casper Original provides more support.
You don’t need a special bed frame for a Casper mattress, although many of the customers who left Casper Element reviews claim they placed theirs on a platform bed frame or boxspring.
Once you unpack the Casper mattress, it should take 24 to 48 hours to completely take shape. Casper Element reviews from customers say the Casper mattress is ready to go sooner than that.
A queen size Original Casper Mattress retails for $1,095.