Casper vs Tempur-Pedic Mattress Comparison
They're both popular mattress brands, but in the Casper vs TempurPedic debate, who wins?
Last Updated: September 2, 2020Matt Ross
When it comes to the different mattress options you have out there, both Casper and TempurPedic are respected kings of the castle. If you’re shopping for a mattress and doing your research, you’ve probably seen these brand names pop up on your computer screen once or twice. So what’s all the hubbub about? In this post we’re going to cover the main selling points of a bed in a box versus a memory foam mattress.
|AT A GLANCE||PRICING||HEADLINE|
|Soft Foam||$100 Off Code: SLUMBERYARD||Casper Original is the mattress that started it all. If you just want a comfortable foam mattress, it’s hard to do better than Casper.|
|Memory Foam||Check Current Offers Applied in Cart||The TempurPedic TEMPUR-Adapt is an accommodating memory foam mattress that is available in both Medium and Medium Hybrid options.|
Casper vs Tempur-Pedic Mattress Comparison Outline
These are the main things you need to know when comparing Casper vs. Tempur-Pedic:
- Price: The original Casper mattress usually costs about $1,000 to $1,500 less than Tempur-Pedic.
- Feel and construction: Tempur-Pedic has a traditional memory foam feel while Casper has a soft-foam feel with zoned support.
- Firmness: Casper has a medium firmness level, whereas you can choose from a range of different softness/firmness levels with Tempur-Pedic.
- Other beds: In addition to the most popular models, we also discuss Casper Wave vs. Tempur-Pedic.
Jump-To Links For This Comparison:
Casper Vs Tempur-Pedic Comparison Video
Casper was a pioneer in the online mattress shopping industry and remains one of the top five most popular brands. It’s easy to understand why — especially when you consider how universally comfortable and well-received their mattress has proven to be.
Casper also offers the Casper Wave, which is the premium bed-in-a-box mattress, the Casper Element, which is a more budget-friendly offering from the brand, the Casper Wave Hybrid and the Casper Hybrid.
Tempur-Pedic has been around since before online mattresses came into the mainstream. When you think of traditional memory foam, Tempur-Pedic is likely one of the first beds that come to mind. The company created a new series to compete with the bed-in-a-box mattresses, even though Tempur-Pedic isn’t considered among those brands. We’re here to pit the two powerhouses against each other.
Casper Mattress Review
What’s Inside The Original Casper Mattress?
If you were to cut your mattress in half with a chainsaw, you would see a foam mattress with three layers (except for Casper Wave Hybrid, which has coils on the inside). While we don’t condone butchering your mattress, we destroyed ours so you could see the inside.
What we saw is a dense base layer of support foam to act as the foundation of your mattress.
The next layer is a slab of transition memory foam with a zoned support design. In other words, the transition layer is divided into three parts with two firmness levels. The top and bottom third are equipped with more pressure-relieving foam and firmer foam in the middle where you need that extra support.
The top is a layer of Casper’s Open-Cell foam that features something called “AirScape.” It’s a proprietary foam, meaning the company manufactured it themselves specifically for their mattress. In this case, we’d call this proprietary foam neutral.
How Does The Casper Mattress Feel?
If you’re a lover of soft, neutral-foam, we think Casper would probably be a great fit for you. Even though memory foam is present in the bed, the proprietary foam on top offsets the sinking feeling that traditional memory foam is known for. Some people love that feeling, and others take a hard pass on it. Casper’s soft foam feel, however, is a little harder to talk negatively about than memory foam.
On our scale from soft to firm, the Casper mattress lands at a medium, which could be another reason so many people like it. Medium firmness levels accommodate the most people because they’re firm enough to support stomach and back sleepers without causing an unaligned spine but soft enough to provide pressure relief to side sleepers.
We think combo sleepers should also enjoy this mattress because it has a quicker response time than other foam beds we have tested out, making it easier for you to switch positions in bed without waking up.
For individuals who weigh over 250 lbs, we recommend the Casper Wave Hybrid or the Casper Nova Hybrid. The best mattresses to provide adequate support for heavy-set individuals tend to be hybrids because they contain springs that provide extra resistance for the pressure your body is exerting.
Tempur-Pedic vs Casper Prices
For some people, buying a mattress is one of the largest purchases they’ll make in their lifetime other than a house and a car. For others, spending more than $2,000 seems excessive. The table below outlines the price for each mattress:
On one side of the coin, you’ll probably keep your mattress for 8-12 years, so you want to make sure it’s nice and supportive enough for you. On the other side, there are many comfortable mattresses out there with a price tag that’ll keep your wallet happy. So, it all depends on your circumstances and preference.
Tempur-Pedic’s flagship TEMPUR-Adapt line comes with several mattress models. Right now, the queen-size TEMPUR-Adapt goes for around $2,200, which the company calls an “everyday value.” Next you have the mid-tier mattress from the series called TEMPUR-ProAdapt, which retails around $3,000. Finally, the highest-grade model — called the TEMPUR-LuxeAdapt — currently retails for about $4,000.
Regardless of which Tempur-Pedic mattress you’re considering, Casper is going to be considerably more affordable.
Casper Wave vs Tempur-Pedic
Like many other brands, Casper has a “good-better-best” model where the original mattress is the “better” model and Casper Wave is the “best” model. Given how expensive the Tempur-Pedic mattresses are, many people are wondering how Casper’s “best” model compares. In this section, we will go over the Tempur-Pedic vs. Casper Wave comparison debate.
Why would someone pay more for Casper Wave over the Original mattress? There are two main points, but the most compelling is the advanced zoned support featured on the Wave mattress:
- Upgraded zoned support: The Original Casper has a zoned support layer whereby the bed is divided into thirds with the center third featuring a slightly denser/firmer foam for added support. Casper Wave also has a zoned support design, but it’s more advanced. Rather than using three foams, the Wave has little targeted gel pods to make the center third more supportive.
- Thicker design: The Wave is 12″ thick while the Original is 11″ thick. This won’t drive any decisions, but it does make the Wave more attractive to people who want a luxury mattress. It’s also worth noting that the Wave has five layers of foam — including latex foam — while the Original has three layers.
The story here is similar to what we’ve already discussed with these two brands. Casper Wave has a more neutral overall feel, while Tempur-Pedic uses a dense memory foam. Ignoring firmness, the difference in feel alone should help you pick your favorite.
You will notice that Casper Wave has the wool-infused cover while Tempur-Pedic has the active-cooling cover. If you’re a hot sleeper, you might prefer the active-cooling cover.
Our advice is to pick based on feel. Casper Wave is around a “medium” in terms of firmness and Tempur-Pedic offers a number of firmness options, so you can’t claim a winner on firmness. Again, feel and price are the two big differentiators.
Pros And Cons of Casper Mattress
- Affordable price point
- Ideal for back, stomach, side, and combination sleepers
- Zoned support system
- Not true memory foam feel
- No active-cooling cover
- Not ideal for heavier individuals (> 250 lbs)
Other Casper Reviews:
- Casper Wave Mattress
- Casper Element Mattress
- Casper Nova Mattress
- Casper Essential Mattress
- Casper Mattress Topper
- Casper Pillow
Casper Mattress Ratings
- Better Business Bureau (BBB) Rating: The BBB gives Casper Sleep Inc. an A+ rating on its website.
- Amazon Reviews: Amazon reviewers give the Casper Original mattress a 4.4-star rating, citing it for its sleep quality, comfort and pain relief.
Tempur-Pedic Mattress Review
Construction Of Tempur-Pedic Adapt Series Mattresses
The TEMPUR-Adapt series includes three models: the TEMPUR-Adapt, the TEMPUR-ProAdapt and the TEMPUR-LuxeAdapt. They all have similar constructions, with the main differences being foam density, cooling technology, a foam or coil base and mattress thickness. For the sake of simplicity, we’re only going to breakdown the inside of a TEMPUR-Adapt.
The base layer on a TEMPUR-Adapt is a thick slab of dense poly foam (or coils with the hybrid model). Next is a transition layer for additional support that sits under two layers of memory foam. Depending on which model you go with, it’ll either have the softer feeling TEMPER-ES, the pressure relieving TEMPUR-APR memory foam, or a mix of both. Either way, it’ll feel like traditional dense memory foam.
One of the major complaints people have with memory foam mattresses is that they can retain heat as you sleep throughout the night. Tempur-Pedic listened: In the new Adapt series, each cover comes with a cool-to-the touch outer layer so it efficiently counteracts the body heat trapped inside the memory foam, resulting in a temperature-neutral mattress, rather than an overly warm one.
If you sleep hot check out our post on Best Cooling Mattresses for Hot Sleepers to see what kind of beds will actively cool you down.
TEMPUR-Adapt Mattress Feel
The mattresses in the Adapt series have a wide selection of firmness levels, ranging from soft to firm, but the most affordable TEMPUR-Adapt line has a medium and medium hybrid — both of which are priced the same.
Regardless of how soft or firm they are, they’ll all feel like traditional memory foam. This means you’ll sink into the mattress and the foam will provide great pressure relief while it contours to the curves of your body. We called the soft bed a medium on our scale, the medium/medium hybrid a medium-firm, and we agreed the firm feels like a firm on our rating system.
Because there are several firmness levels, any type of sleeper (side, back, stomach, and combo) can find a mattress in the Adapt series that’ll suit their preference. Tempur-Pedic also offers a split king and a split California king mattress, so if you favor firm beds but sleep with a partner who’d rather sleep on the couch than a firm mattress, you’re each able to get the firmness level you need.
Pros And Cons Of Tempur-Pedic
- Traditional memory foam feel
- Cool-to-the-touch outer layer
- Ideal for back, stomach, side, and combination sleepers
- Not as supportive
- Harder to switch positions during the night
Other Tempur-Pedic Reviews
- Tempur-Pedic Hybrid Reviews
- Tempur-Pedic Adjustable Base
- TEMPUR-Topper Supreme
- Best Tempur-Pedic Pillow Reviews
Tempur-Pedic Mattress Ratings
How Your Weight Affects The Feel Of Your Mattress
If you take two people with drastically different body types — for example, an average 11-year-old boy versus an ex-linebacker for the Denver Broncos — and have them lay on a bed, each person will rate the bed differently than the other. For the 11-year-old, his body weight won’t apply that much pressure to the bed, so a medium mattress might feel a little firmer to him. For the ex-linebacker, he’d probably say the bed felt softer to him due to the amount of pressure his body applies to the bed.
With that being said, the original Casper mattress is an all-foam bed, so it wouldn’t hold up too well for somebody like the ex-linebacker we just mentioned. If you have a heavier body type, we suggest you look into Casper’s new hybrid mattresses or the two hybrid mattress models in the Tempur-Pedic Adapt series.
Which Bed Should I Purchase?
It depends on your personal preference. The Casper mattress provides a firmer option while still being soft enough to accommodate all types of sleepers. Casper mattresses are also much less expensive than their Tempur-Pedic counterparts. On the other hand, Tempur-Pedic mattresses have a more traditional memory foam feel and enhanced durability. You’ll simply have to feel them both to get a better idea of how your body will respond.
Tempur-Pedic vs. Casper Verdict
So which mattress should you go with, the memory foam Tempur-Pedic or the neutral-foam Casper? Here are the major indicators to help you decide which mattress would probably be best for you:
- Do you prefer neutral, soft foam over memory foam? Casper has that soft, neutral-foam feel you’d probably find comfortable.
- Are you looking for the more affordable option? Casper is the more budget-friendly mattress between the two.
- Do you want to choose between firmness levels? Or, if you’re a couple, choose how soft/firm you want your side to be? A Tempur-Pedic has soft, medium, and firm mattresses, and also provides the option to get a split king/California king.
If you have other mattresses you want to compare, check out our Mattress Comparison Page to see if we’ve covered it. You can also stay up-to-date on current mattress deals over at our Mattress Deals page.
The biggest differences between the Casper and Tempur-Pedic mattresses are the price point and general mattress feel. Casper mattresses are less expensive by about $1,000 and have a soft, neutral-foam feel. Tempur-Pedic mattresses have a higher price point and provide a more traditional memory foam feel.
It depends on your personal preference. Many people prefer the traditional memory foam feel that Tempur-Pedic beds provide. Especially for those seeking a soft, memory foam mattress that counteracts body heat absorption, the Tempur-Pedic mattresses are a great option. Again, the only way to truly tell if a Tempur-Pedic is worth the money is by trying one out for yourself!
If you select the memory foam options from Casper or Tempur-Pedic, you will not need a box spring for your bed. However, if you select a hybrid model with springs, you will need to purchase a box spring in addition to your mattress to ensure optimal comfort.