Cocoon vs Nectar Mattress Comparison
If you can only get one memory foam mattress, should it be Cocoon by Sealy or Nectar Sleep?
Last Updated: September 11, 2020McKenzie Dillon
In the e-commerce space, memory foam mattresses are everywhere. Nectar and Sealy Cocoon are among the most popular, however, and in this comparison we will examine why you might want to get one bed over the other. We will touch on everything from overall feel to return policies.
|AT A GLANCE||PRICING||HEADLINE|
|Memory Foam||35% Off Code: SY35||Cocoon Chill is one of the best budget-tier cooling mattresses. It’s a firmer bed with a dense memory foam feel.|
|Memory Foam||Free Gifts w/ Mattress Purchase||Nectar could be the most popular memory foam mattress online. It’s affordable, comfortable, and usually comes with free pillows.|
Nectar vs. Cocoon Mattress Overview
Both Nectar and Cocoon are among the major players in the bed-in-a-box industry. Cocoon’s parent company, Sealy, also owns Tempur-Pedic. But Sealy’s beginnings stretch back to the late 1800s.
As for Nectar, it’s a new company, but that doesn’t stop it from being one of the more popular mattress brands on the market. In the first year of business alone, the company sold $55 million worth of mattresses and bedding products, according to Inc Magazine. The company continues to grow rapidly and competes directly with the likes of Cocoon, Leesa and Casper.
Because there’s a lot to cover in this comparison, here’s a quick synopsis of the main points that we’ll be covering:
- Models: Cocoon has two models, while Nectar has one.
- Pricing: Cocoon and Nectar are both borderline budget mattresses.
- Design: We are going to dissect both beds to show what’s inside.
- Shipping and returns: Both are free.
- Firmness and feel: While Nectar and Cocoon are both memory foam beds, they feel different.
Jump-To Links For This Comparison:
Now that you have a basic idea of how this comparison will shake out, let’s dive into our in-depth reviews.
Cocoon Mattress Review
Cocoon Chill & Classic Models
Cocoon offers a great option for hot sleepers seeking comfort on a limited budget — especially when selecting the Cocoon Chill model. This memory foam mattress has much to offer, including a 100-night trial period, 10-year warranty and free shipping and returns.
Before we discuss the advantages of Cocoon we should clarify that we’re dealing with two mattress models:
- Cocoon Classic: A memory foam mattress for the budget-minded shopper.
- Cocoon Chill: The same mattress as the Classic but with a cooling cover for warmer sleepers.
Both models are also available in a soft and firm comfort profile, which allows you the flexibility to select whichever you think is best for you.
Cocoon Mattress Construction And Materials
Cocoon has a basic construction that includes either two or three layers of foam, depending on which model you choose. The following outlines how each model is constructed:
- Firm: This version includes a poly foam support core and a memory foam comfort layer.
- Soft: This uses the same poly foam support core and memory foam comfort layer but has an added transition layer to soften up the mattress.
To be clear, there’s no right or wrong choice here with Cocoon — it all comes down to your firmness preferences. If you want the slightly softer model, go with the soft option. But if you prefer to sleep exclusively on your stomach or back, you might enjoy the firm model more.
Cocoon Feel And Firmness
Despite the fact that Cocoon calls them “soft” and “firm,” those aren’t apt names for the firmness ratings. We consider both models to be closer to a medium-firm. The soft version sits just below a true medium-firm, and the firm is a hair firmer than a medium-firm.
Cocoon Sleeper Type Analysis
As we mentioned above, Cocoon soft and “Firm” are both firmer in general. As such, we consider the soft model to be okay for back, stomach and combination sleepers, while the firm model is for back and stomach sleepers due to its firmness level.
Because of the Cocoon’s firmness level, we think it’s a suitable mattress for any sleeper — big or small. Depending on how much you weigh, different sleepers will get a different feeling from the Cocoon.
If you weigh less than 200lbs, you’ll likely agree that the mattress feels firm rather than having a traditional memory foam feel. If you weigh more than 250lbs, you may argue that the mattress is closer to a medium on the firmness scale.
Cocoon Chill’s Temperature Regulation
If you’re a hot sleeper who loves memory foam, Cocoon Chill is a nice option. It’s not as cool as GhostBed Luxe, but it’s also a lot more affordable. The bed has a special cover that tries to actively cool down the sleeper. You can read more about Cocoon Chill on the website.
Cocoon Pros And Cons
- Budget-friendly pricing
- Cooling cover on the Cocoon Chill
- Comfortable design for back/stomach sleepers
- Firmer than traditional memory foam
- Not great for those who prefer innerspring beds
- Side sleepers may not be comfortable
Other Cocoon Products
Cocoon Mattress Ratings
- Better Business Bureau (BBB): Tempur Sealy International Inc. (the creators of Cocoon by Sealy) has earned an A- rating according to the BBB site.
- Amazon Reviews: Amazon reviewers rate the Cocoon mattress a 4.4 out of 5 stars for its softness, sleep quality and comfort.
Cocoon vs. Nectar Pricing
One of the biggest selling points with Cocoon and Nectar is the pricing.
Nectar, for example, is about $800 for a queen size bed, and you often get two free pillows with your purchase. Cocoon, on the other hand, plays around with pricing. As of August 2020, the queen-size Chill mattress had an MSRP between $900 and $1,000. After-discount, however, Cocoon Chill drops to around the $700 price point and sometimes includes a free pillow and sheet set.
The bottom line is that Nectar and Cocoon should be under $1,000 for the queen size, both pre- and post-discount. Historically speaking, that makes them both highly affordable, if not safely in the budget category.
Nectar Mattress Review
Nectar Construction And Materials
When comparing Nectar vs. Cocoon, there are many striking similarities. However, while the Cocoon mattress falls on the firmer side, the Nectar mattress offers a more plush feel for those who prefer a softer, more traditional memory foam bed. Let’s dive into what makes the Nectar vs. Cocoon debate so interesting.
We cut open the Nectar (and Cocoon) mattress to see what’s inside; though, we caution you to not do the same. In any case, Nectar is an all-foam bed with several layers. Here’s a look at what’s inside the bed:
- Bottom layer: Dense poly foam
- Middle layer: Memory foam
- Primary comfort layer: Viscose memory foam and gel memory foam
In the primary comfort layer, the gel memory foam is quilted into the cover, which adds to the overall dense, memory foam feel. It also provides extra cushioning to the mattress.
Nectar Mattress Feel And Firmness
Nectar is right in between a medium and medium-firm, a bit like the Cocoon soft version. As we’ve mentioned, Nectar will have a true memory foam feel. You sink in and the bed provides a nice amount of pressure ief.
Nectar Sleeper Type Analysis
Sitting between a medium and medium-firm on our firmness scale, Nectar is able to accommodate almost any sleep style. However, if you’re a petite side sleeper, you’ll likely want to look for a softer mattress. While you do sink in a bit and the mattress provides some pressure ief, it’s not nearly enough for side sleepers to rest comfortably through the night, in our opinion.
We think it’s safe to say that back, stomach and combination sleepers will fall in love with the Nectar mattress.
Nectar Is Best For Lean Sleepers
Nectar mattresses do not have coils and fall right in the middle on the firmness scale, which means they’re mostly intended for sleepers weighing less than 230lbs. That said, heavier folks may still find the mattress comfortable if they prefer a softer-feeling mattress. However, we advise those weighing in at more than 250lbs to opt for a hybrid or innerspring mattress to get that extra bit of support that most memory foam mattresses just can’t provide.
Nectar Testing And Returns
In the world of online beds, free return policies are common — as are 100-night test windows — but a full-year test window is rare to see. That is indeed what Nectar offers. You can test the bed for an entire year before you have to make a firm commitment either way. Cocoon also has a trial period, but it’s 100 nights. Pretty crazy to think that both companies will allow you to try their beds for several months before you decide to keep it or not.
Nectar Pros And Cons
- Budget-friendly pricing
- Great for back, stomach and combo sleepers
- Traditional memory foam feel
- Not ideal for side sleepers
- Not suitable for heavier folks (> 230lbs)
- May not be firm enough for some sleepers
Other Nectar Products
Nectar Mattress Ratings
- Better Business Bureau (BBB): Due to the short amount of time that Nectar has been in business, BBB does not currently have a rating for the company, nor is the company BBB accredited.
- Amazon Reviews: Amazon reviewers rate the Nectar mattress a 4 out of 5 stars for its sleep quality, comfort, and value for the money.
Nectar vs Cocoon Review Verdict
Here are the major questions that you should be asking yourself when considering Nectar vs. Cocoon:
- What’s your budget? Both beds are affordable, but Nectar is often a little less expensive.
- What’s your dominant sleep style? If you said back or stomach, Cocoon has the firmer models; though, we consider Nectar to be a nice option as well. For side sleepers, we would give Nectar a slight edge.
- Are you fine with a three-month trial window? We consider it to be more than long enough, but if you need more time, Nectar has the longer trial period.
- What’s your weight? If you’re over 230 lbs, you should check out our list of the Best Mattresses For Heavy and Obese People.
- Do you want to try a cooling mattress? Cocoon Chill is a nice place to start because it has the phase change cover.
If you need more details, read our full reviews of the two beds.
Cocoon mattresses are only available for online purchase, not in any retail locations. However, Nectar mattresses are available in nearly 1,500 brick-and-mortar locations nationwide for those who prefer to test drive before making a purchase. Both companies offer a risk-free trial period, however, to help customers avoid getting stuck with a mattress that doesn’t suit their sleeping needs.
It depends on your personal preference. If you prefer a firmer-feeling mattress, we recommend going with the Cocoon. However, if a softer mattress is more your style, Nectar is probably the way to go. It all comes down to what you like best!
Both Nectar and Cocoon offer a risk-free trial period. During this time, if you find that your mattress doesn’t suit your comfort needs, you can return your mattress for a full refund — free of charge.