Leesa vs. Casper Mattress
Which top-rated bed-in-a-box mattress would be the best match for you? Find out in this Leesa vs. Casper review.
Last Updated: August 12, 2020
Leesa vs. Casper are both popular mattress brands. Leesa mattresses are made in the U.S.A. with a company commitment to do good within the community. Casper was founded in 2014 and rose in popularity from influencer and celebrity endorsements. The Casper Original is 11” thick firmer mattress than the 10” Leesa model. Casper may be the less expensive choice when furnishing a kid’s room or small guest room, with the twin and twin XL being less expensive. As for the larger full, queen and king sizes, the Leesa mattress will come in at roughly $100 to $200 less.
There’s a chance you’ve been wanting to compare Casper vs. Leesa because they’re two huge names you keep seeing everywhere on the Internet. Both brands are incredibly popular with considerably similar features. There are a few key things that set them apart from each other, and we’ll be touching on those points as well as price, coupons, firmness, feel and company policies.
|AT A GLANCE||PRICING||HEADLINE|
|Soft Foam||15% Off Code: SLUMBERYARD||Leesa Original is one of the top five bed-in-a-box mattresses out there. It has a soft foam feel and is accommodating for a wide range of sleepers.|
|Soft Foam||$100 Off Code: SLUMBERYARD||Casper Original is the mattress that started it all. If you just want a comfortable foam mattress, it’s hard to do better than Casper.|
Here’s a quick overview of the main differences between Leesa vs. Casper:
They are both entirely made out of foam, but Casper is manufactured with zoned support framework.
Leesa is more philanthropic than Casper is.
You have the choice between a light and airy neutral foam vs. soft, comfortable foam.
Leesa is the more affordable option.
Let’s dive into the details you’ve been waiting for.
Casper vs. Leesa: Introduction To Online Mattresses
Casper might not be the first bed-in-a-box company to step onto the scene, but we think it was one of the first ones to make these beds so popular. Leesa came shortly after and is up there with Casper as one of the most sought-after online mattress brands. Leesa and Casper helped set the precedent that paved the way for others, so now many brands have been quick to follow the standards set by Leesa, Casper and a few other names, like Purple mattress and Tuft & Needle.
We’ll mainly be focused on the original Leesa vs. Casper models, but we think it’s important to note they each offer a more luxury mattress, Leesa Hybrid, Leesa Legend, and Casper Wave. These models are both built to be more supportive and durable, so they’re pricier too.
In early 2019, Casper released two hybrid models, which means the mattresses incorporate both foam and coils. If you can imagine The Casper and The Wav but with pocketed coils, that’s basically what we’re dealing with when it comes to the “Hybrid” options. Check out the full-length Leesa Hybrid review, Leesa Legend review, or Casper Wave review to get more details.
Casper vs. Leesa Price Difference
Both the Leesa and Casper mattresses retail for around $1,000 (queen-size). However, after discounts are applied, Casper usually comes out to be the slightly more expensive bed by about $50-$150. If you’re looking for the more affordable option, Leesa is most likely the answer. You can head over to the Leesa website or Casper website for current pricing.
Construction Of Leesa Mattresses
There are three basic mattress constructions: foam, coils or a combination of both (hybrid). Both Leesa and Casper’s original models are all-foam mattresses, but their constructions are different.
Leesa has three layers, including a 6” slab of dense polyurethane foam to provide a solid foundation, a 2” transition layer made out of memory foam and a final layer of LSA200 Foam at the top. That last foam is a proprietary foam, which is mattress vocabulary for a type of foam manufactured by the company.
Up until September of 2018, Leesa used a foam called Avena foam, but the company updated it to the LSA200, which we think is more comfortable and pressure relieving. The entire mattress is 10” thick, which is an average size for a bed-in-a-box mattress.
The cover is made out of polyester, a semi-synthetic fiber called “viscose” and lycra, which is a more elastic material like you find in athletic wear. It has a grey quilt-like pattern with four white horizontal stripes, so it has an attractive look to complement its comfortableness. It’s technically removable, but we suggest you keep it on. Sometimes it can be difficult to put it back on, and we don’t see a point in removing it if you can’t machine wash it. If you do happen to spill on your mattress, you can spot clean it with mild detergent and warm water.
Feel And Responsiveness Of Leesa Mattresses
The first time you lay on a Leesa mattress, you’ll notice you don’t feel the memory foam layer that sits underneath the top layer of that neutral-feeling LSA200 foam. Because the top layer is the one you feel the most, it cancels out any deep viscous feeling the memory foam would otherwise give you. This can either be a good or bad thing, depending on who you ask.
With Leesa, you get a comfortable neutral-foam mattress with a light and airy feel like you’re laying on cotton candy. You don’t sink into the mattress like you do with memory foam; you gently float on top of it. This is one reason why it’s so popular. If a mattress is neutral, it’s much more difficult for someone to be opposed to it.
On our scale from soft to firm, we placed Leesa at a medium, which is another accommodating characteristic of the bed. It balances between being supportive and pressure relieving at the same time.
That means it’s a suitable mattress for all sleeper types, including side, stomach, back and combination sleepers. When we applied pressure to it with our hands, it was quick to bounce back, so combo sleepers will be able to move as much as they want because a responsive bed makes it much easier to switch positions.
Leesa pros and cons
- Medium firmness with an airy feel is good for all sleeper types
- You’re supporting a company that gives back to communities
- Made in the U.S.A.
- Smaller twin sizes are more expensive than Casper’s
- $150 fee for in-home delivery
- Customer reviews mention strong off gassing odor
Other Leesa Products
Leesa Mattress Reviews
- BBB Rating: A+
- Amazon Reviews: Sleepers like that they can’t feel their partner moving around at night and enjoy the soft, yet firm, support. They also commented about the hassle-free returns. However, larger sleepers complained about the mattress sagging over time and some people mentioned a strong off-gassing odor at the beginning.
- Free Shipping & Returns
- 100 Night Trial Period
- 10 Year Warranty
- Made in USA
Zoned Support Framework Construction Of Casper
Similar to Leesa, a Casper mattress is a 11” thick all-foam bed, and it’s made with three layers. The first layer is a dense layer of support foam, then the next is a slab of zoned transition memory foam. The third layer is a proprietary foam called Open-Cell Foam, which is a neutral-foam and the most prominent layer that contributes to the bed’s overall feel.
What we like most about Casper’s construction is the zoned support framework that makes up the mattress’s transition layer. The slab of neutral-foam is divided into three parts; the top and bottom thirds are less firm to accommodate your shoulders and legs, while the middle section is firmer so it can provide proper support to your hip and trunk area. There aren’t too many mattresses with this feature, and we think it’s a nice touch to make the bed appeal to more sleepers.
The knit Casper cover is made out of polyester with neutral colors to finish the bed with a pleasantly clean look. It’s one of the easiest covers to remove, but again we don’t recommend it. Casper does not fall into the category of mattresses with machine washable covers, regardless of the claim on the website that says it’s “easy-to-clean.”
Feel Of Casper Mattress
Leesa and Casper may be similar, but they do have distinct constructions that set them apart from each other.
They’re both constructed with memory foam and neutral-foam (except for Sapira, Casper Hybrid and Casper Wave Hybrid, which have blends of coils and foams). If you remember, we said a Leesa mattress feels like you’re laying on top of a pile of cotton candy. A Casper mattress has a soft neutral-foam feel like you’re laying on top of a giant teddy bear. They’re both extremely pleasant to relax on. It all depends on your preference; light and airy or soft and cozy?
The Casper mattress is rated at around the same spot as Leesa on our softness to firmness scale—right in the middle at a medium. That said, we’d consider Casper slightly softer than Leesa. Again, this ensures it’s generally suitable for all sleeper types and has a broader appeal.
We wouldn’t doubt this characteristic is a big contributing factor to Leesa and Casper’s popularity because many people want to be somewhere in the middle ground between soft and firm. It’s also a more responsive mattress than other all-foam beds, which is a plus for you combo sleepers out there because that means it’ll be easier to switch positions while you sleep without having to struggle to turn over.
Casper Pros And Cons
- Softer neutral foam feel than Leesa
- Three-zone support framework for better comfort
- Expands when out of the box in minutes
- More expensive than Leesa in the queen and king sizes
- Customer claims of inconsistent mattress sizing
- Neutral foam may not provide enough support for larger individuals
Other Casper Products
Casper Mattress Reviews
- BBB rating: A+
Amazon reviews: Reviewers say that Casper sleeps cool and is extremely comfortable and supportive for all sleeping positions. People had a few complaints baout poor customer service, including some people saying the 100-day return policy wasn’t honored.
- Free Shipping & Returns
- 100 Night Trial Period
- 10 Year Warranty
- Zoned Support Foam
- Hybrid Option
Which One Should I Buy?
If you’re on a budget, Leesa’s larger mattress sizes (full, queen and king) are less expensive than Casper’s. Casper beats Leesa on price in the twin and twin XL size.
Casper vs. Leesa
When evaluating the Casper vs. Leesa, both original versions are similar. The main differences may include pricepoint — Leesa is less expensive in the full, queen or king sizes. Casper is 1” thicker at 11” to Leesa’s 10” mattress. They’re similar in firmness scale at a medium, although Casper may have a softer feel.
Both companies have additional luxury options. Besides the original, Casper offers the Element and Wave Hybrid model. If you’re looking for Leesa options, check out the Hybrid and Legend mattresses.
Casper may be a more versatile mattress for all types of sleepers. The three-zone support feature means you can comfortably sleep in any position. Leesa’s soft, supportive foam may be best for side sleepers.
Leesa vs. Casper: Verdict
- Do you prefer an airy foam feel or a soft foam feel? Leesa’s neutral-foam has a lighter feel than Casper’s soft neutral-foam.
- Would you rather purchase a mattress from a company who donates to charity and contributes to improving the environment? Leesa is one of the most philanthropic companies out there.
- Do you want Zoned Support Framework in your mattress, meaning firmer foam where you need it most? You might want to consider a Casper mattress.
- Are you a more price-conscious buyer? Leesa is usually ~$50-$150 cheaper than Casper after taking into account coupon codes and discounts.
If you’re interested in how Casper and Leesa stack up against other mattresses in the industry, take a scroll through our mattress comparisons page.
Leesa Hybrid vs. Casper Hybrid
While most people are primarily thinking of the Original Casper and Leesa when they start looking for comparisons, the companies’ hybrid models are becoming increasingly popular as well.
As a heads up, Leesa Hybrid used to be called Sapira, and Casper Hybrid isn’t an official product because Casper gives you the option to add coils to the Original mattress, thereby making it a hybrid mattress. In any case, here’s a video that compares Leesa Sapira Hybrid vs. Casper Hybrid:
For those of you that would prefer a written comparison, here’s how the Leesa Hybrid vs. Casper Hybrid story plays out:
If you can imagine the Original Leesa mattress with 6″ pocketed coils, that’s Leesa Hybrid. However, the bed is also firmer, more supportive, and more costly.
We rate Leesa Hybrid at about a medium-firm, making it firmer than Casper Hybrid. Therefore, if you’re a stomach or back sleeper, you will probably prefer to sleep on Leesa Hybrid. That’s the biggest difference between these two hybrids for the average consumer.
This mattress is the Original Casper mattress with coils. It’s still 12″ thick and has the same soft foam feel with more bounce. The coils themselves are pocketed (or individually-wrapped) like those inside Leesa Hybrid.
In terms of construction, these two beds are similar, but, again, the main difference has to do with firmness. Casper Hybrid is about a “medium” while Leesa Hybrid is in the “medium-firm” range. That means side sleepers will prefer Casper Hybrid.
Leesa Legend vs. Casper Wave
The newest mattress in Leesa’s lineup is called the Legend, and it is most comparable to Casper Wave in terms of construction and price point. In this section we will do a Leesa Legend vs Casper Wave head-to-head comparison.
While Leesa Hybrid is a premium mattress, Leesa Legend is a luxury bed. It’s still a hybrid mattress, but it features a “zoned support” design like what we see on The Wave mattress. Leesa achieves this by having a layer cut into thirds with the center being denser foam and the top and bottom being comprised of 1.5″ micro-springs.
The overall feel of the bed is similar to that of The Wave, but it’s softer. We rate Leesa Legend at about a medium, which puts it in a similar range as The Wave, only slightly softer. Therefore, as it relates to side sleepers, we have to give the edge to Leesa Legend.
The original Casper Wave is a 13″ foam mattress, but you can also add coils to the bed, making the Casper Wave Hybrid. It also is the first online mattress to have zoned support, which means the Casper Wave Hybrid has the same general construction as Leesa Legend.
That said, the zoned support inside Casper Wave is achieved by the addition of little gel pods to make it firmer in the center third. Here’s a look inside Casper Wave:
From the outside, you can’t tell whether you’re looking at Casper Wave or Casper Wave Hybrid, but once you lay down, you’ll experience a little more bounce with the hybrid. Therefore, The Wave Hybrid makes more sense for heavier individuals than does the original foam version.
The Wave sits around a “medium” according to our testers, which means it’s slightly firmer than the Leesa Legend mattress. As such, if you’re a strict back/stomach sleeper, The Wave is a smarter pick.
Leesa Studio vs. Casper / Casper Element
In this section, we will directly compare Leesa Studio vs. Casper Original. These are both foam mattresses, and they have a lot in common. Here’s a quick list of the overlapping qualities for Leesa Studio and Casper:
- Foam mattresses that have three layers
- Both beds use neutral foam and memory foam
- Free shipping/returns, 100-night trial and 10-year warranty
- Best for medium and petite-size sleepers
- Around a “medium” on our firmness/softness scale
At a high level, both of these are comfortable foam mattresses. Having said that, there are a few key areas where we see separation with Leesa Studio and Casper. Here’s that list:
- Leesa Studio is significantly more affordable at about $700 for the queen.
- Casper Original can be found in an all-foam version and hybrid version.
- Casper is a little taller at about 10.5” thick.
- Casper Original has “Zoned Support” while Leesa Studio is three layers of foam.
Do you prefer Casper because of the hybrid option and “Zoned Support,” or would you rather save money with Leesa Studio and get a basic, soft foam mattress?
In terms of the Leesa Studio vs. Casper Element question, we see these beds as almost perfectly analogous because they’re both 10” foam bed-in-a-box mattresses. That said, there are some differences that you might be interested in learning more about.
For instance, Casper Element has two layers of foam, but its top layer is an “Airscape” foam that’s designed to pull through more airflow. So, while you have fewer layers of foam, you do get an interesting main comfort layer on Casper Element.
Leesa Studio, on the other hand, has the three layers, including a transition layer. Both will have a “soft foam” feel and should be comfortable for most types of sleepers. So long as you’re a medium-sized or petite sleeper, we think you should be happy with them.
The biggest difference is the price tag. Casper Element is around $600 for the queen, while Leesa Studio is about $700.