Puffy vs Nectar Mattress
It's a bed-in-a-box showdown - see who wins in the debate between Nectar vs. Puffy.
Last Updated: July 14, 2020
If you’re shopping for a mattress-in-a-box, you’ve probably heard of Puffy and Nectar. Both companies hit the market in 2016, and they’ve been selling high-quality mattresses ever since. Puffy and Nectar are known for their affordable mattresses and lifetime warranties. However, there are some differences between these companies and the mattresses they sell. We’ll get into the details to help you determine whether Puffy vs. Nectar is right for you.
|AT A GLANCE||PRICING||HEADLINE|
|Mixed Foam||$300 Off + Gift Discount In Cart||Puffy is one of the best known online mattresses. It has three layers of foam and a comfortable, accommodating “feel.”|
|Memory Foam||$100 Off + Gift Applied In Cart||Nectar could be the most popular memory foam mattress online. It’s affordable, comfortable, and usually comes with free pillows.|
Puffy Mattress vs. Nectar synopsis
In today’s internet age, everybody wants the quick facts right away. To cater to that crowd, here are the primary differences between these two bed-in-a-box mattresses.
- Feel — The Puffy mattress has a neutral-foam feel, while the Nectar mattress has more of a pure play memory foam feel.
- Firmness — The Nectar mattress is a notch or two firmer than the Puffy.
- Price — Nectar is more affordable than Puffy, plain and simple.
- Special Cover – The Puffy mattress uses a cover that is both stain resistant and machine washable.
Those are the main differences. However, if you’re serious about these two beds, we recommend checking out the sections below to learn more about Nectar and Puffy. If you’re more interested in hearing about how the Puffy Lux compares to Nectar, you can use the link below to jump directly ahead to that section.
To start, we’ll primarily be concentrating on the Original Puffy mattress.
Puffy Has A Neutral Foam Feel
The Puffy mattress is an all-foam bed with three layers. For the top comfort layer, the company uses a special proprietary foam calledCooling Cloud Foam. It’s a light, airy memory foam feel.
However, because the top layer is only 2″ thick and not actually memory foam, we wouldn’t consider Puffy to be a true memory foam mattress. Instead, we’d say the bed has more of a neutral-foam feel, meaning the top layers don’t conform to your body as much as the Nectar mattress. The Puffy mattress has a comfortable, soft foam feel with a hint of memory foam.
There’s no winner or “best feel” in terms of neutral-foam vs. true memory foam. It comes down to what you prefer. We like the feel of both mattresses, so it’s tough to speculate on which feel you’d like better.
Puffy Is Slightly Softer Than Nectar
Another big difference between Nectar vs. Puffy is firmness. Overall, we think the Puffy mattress comes in around a medium on the firmness scale. The bed strikes a nice balance between comfort and support.
As such, we think the Puffy mattress is ideal for all kinds of sleepers. Side sleepers will find that the bed provides ample pressure relief, and back and stomach sleepers will receive the necessary support they need. As you will find out later in this comparison, Nectar also accommodates all sleeper types, but it’s slightly firmer than Puffy.
Another interesting aspect of the Puffy mattress is its cover. To be more specific, the cover is removable, stain-resistant and machine washable. Most bed-in-a-box mattress covers are removable, but the vast majority of them are not stained resistant and washable. You can read up about the cover on Puffy’s website.
As you can see above, the liquid Slumber Yard team member Jeff spills on the cover simply beads right off the side of the bed. This is good news for folks who either don’t use a mattress protector or like to eat and drink in bed. If you do have an accident, you can wash the cover. With most other bed-in-a-box mattresses, you’d have to spot clean the cover.
Puffy Pros And Cons
- Extremely comfortable for a wide range of sleepers
- Frequently offers promotional deals
- Offers a 101-night test period
- Not suited for people who want a very soft or very firm mattress
- No memory foam inside the mattress
- More expensive than some competitors (including Nectar)
Other Puffy Products
- Puffy comforter
- Puffy mattress topper
- Puffy adjustable base
Puffy Mattress Reviews
- BBB Rating: A+
- Amazon Reviews: Puffy isn’t sold on Amazon. It is exclusively available through Puffy.com.
Puffy Lux vs Nectar Comparison
For those of you who are unaware, the company also offers another mattress called the Puffy Lux. It’s a premium all-foam bed that is slightly softer than the flagship Puffy mattress. Here’s a short video that outlines how the Lux compares to Nectar.
In our eyes, the decision between Nectar and Puffy Lux boils down to your budget, firmness preference and primary sleeping position.
Nectar Has A Dense Memory Foam Feel
If you’re a big memory fan, it’s time to perk up. The Nectar mattress uses three layers of memory foam in total and, as a result, has a dense memory foam feel.
When you first lay down, the mattress feels firm and you don’t sink in that much. However, after a couple seconds, you’ll start to nestle into the bed and the top memory foam layers conform to your body. Bottom line, if you like the feel of memory foam, you’d likely enjoy sleeping on the Nectar mattress.
Nectar Is Slightly Firmer Than Puffy
As mentioned above, the Nectar mattress is a tad bit firmer than Puffy. You don’t sink as much and your hips stay a little more in horizontal alignment with the rest of your body. Overall, we think the bed comes in around a medium to medium-firm on the firmness scale.
Still, despite being on the firmer side, we think the mattress is a good choice for all types of sleepers. The bed provides a good amount of support for back and stomach sleepers. When it comes to side sleepers, at first, the bed doesn’t seem ideal due to the firmness, but once you nestle into the top layers, it’s a comfortable mattress. After a few seconds, the top layers do a good job of cradling your pressure points (hips and shoulders) when you’re on your side.
Nectar Is More Affordable
The Nectar mattress is cheaper than Puffy. A queen-size Nectar has an MSRP of about $800, while the Puffy queen mattress has an MSRP of $1,150. Both companies offer discounts, and you can expect Nectar’s promotions to be in the $100 price range.
However, the MSRP doesn’t mean much in Puffy’s case because they are almost always running a big promotion. We regularly see Puffy offer $250-$300 off MSRP. It might be a good idea to check Puffy.com to see what the current promotion is. After discount, you’ll most likely be able to snag a queen-size Puffy for around $850. It’s also worth noting that Nectar typically throws in two free pillows with each mattress purchase.
If the prices listed above are outside your budget, we’d recommend checking out our list of the Best Beds Under $500.
Nectar Pros And Cons
- Extremely affordable for all bed sizes
- Built with cooling memory foam
- Includes a lifetime warranty
- Not for someone who wants a firm mattress
- Not suited for heavier people
- Some buyers complain about the customer service
Other Nectar Products
- Nectar adjustable bed frame
- Nectar mattress protector
- Nectar nightstand
Nectar Mattress Reviews
- BBB Rating: Nectar is not rated by the BBB.
- Amazon Reviews: Overall, Amazon reviewers have excellent things to say about Nectar’s mattress. Most people are satisfied with the comfort and were happy with the price. However, a few people complained about the mattress being too firm or had issues with the company’s customer service.
What Puffy And Nectar Have In Common
As you read above, there are some key differences in feel, firmness and price. However, these two beds also have some important commonalities to note.
Both Beds Are Not Ideal For Heavy People
One potential downside with both Puffy and Nectar is that they are not the best options for heavy people because of their constructions. At the end of the day, both mattresses are comprised entirely of foam and total 10″ and 11″ thick, respectively.
We almost always steer big people towards beds that contain coils, whether they’re individually pocketed or part of an innerspring system. That’s because coils are more durable and also provide more resistance against pressure than dense support foams, which both Nectar and Puffy use for their foundations. As such, if you’re a heavy person (250+ lb), we recommend you check out our list of the Best Mattresses For Heavy People or Best Hybrid Mattresses.
Both Beds Will Work For Couples
We think both Puffy and Nectar are viable options for folks who share a mattress. Both beds limit motion transfer extremely well and alsoprovide decent edge support for being all-foam beds.
Motion transfer isolation is important to consider if one or both partners are active in their sleep (i.e. they move around or get up a lot throughout the night). With beds that isolate motion well (like Puffy and Nectar), you won’t feel as much of your partner’s movements, which will help lead to a more restful night’s sleep.
Edge support is another important topic, especially for couples who share a smaller size mattress, like a full or queen. Beds with solid edge support provide more useful surface area for both partners to spread out and get comfortable without feeling like they’re going to roll off the edge.
Lastly, we think both Puffy and Nectar sleep temperature neutral. In other words, the beds themselves won’t be the primary reason why you warm up or sleep cool at night.
This is always a tough subject to discuss in the bedding industry because external factors play such a large role in how cool or warm you sleep. Often, your sleeping temperature gets pinned on your mattress when, in reality, factors like what climate you live in, how often you run your air conditioner and what type of sheets you use are more important.
Which One Should I Buy?
Buying a mattress comes down to personal preference. If you’re looking for the lowest price, Nectar is your best option. When it comes to feel, know that Puffy’s mixed foam mattress is going to be softer, whereas Nectar’s memory foam mattress is more firm.
Nectar Mattress vs. Puffy Review Verdict
After the last section regarding similarities, you still might be a little confused as to which bed to purchase. In our eyes, the decision comes down to three primary factors.
If you’re tight on cash, go with Nectar. It’s the cheaper mattress, plus the company often throws in two free pillows.
This comes down to personal preference. You have to decide whether you’d like a soft, neutral-foam feel (Puffy) or a slightly firmer, dense memory foam feel (Nectar).
Again, this somewhat comes down to preference. If you want a firmer bed, go Nectar. If you want a slightly softer bed, go with Puffy.
Puffy and Nectar offer free shipping and returns on all their products, including mattresses. Both companies offer fast delivery through FedEx.
In terms of affordability, Nectar has cheaper prices for every mattress size. However, we found that Puffy offers better promotions. That means you could snag a Puffy mattress for cheaper than Nectar if you take advantage of a sale.
Overall, Nectar mattresses are firmer than Puffy mattresses. Part of that is because Nectar mattresses are made of memory foam, which is denser than Puffy’s mixed foam material. Technically, Nectar classifies their mattress as medium-firm, but some Amazon reviewers claim that the mattress is actually much firmer than advertised.
Shipping, Returns, Trial Periods And Warranties
Shopping for and purchasing a bed online is a lot easier than most people realize. Bed-in-a-box companies like Puffy and Nectar try to make it as painless as possible for consumers. Let’s find out how, starting with Puffy.
The Puffy mattress ships via FedEx for free and arrives at your door compressed and rolled up in a box. From there, simply move the box to your room and then just unwrap and unroll the bed onto your frame or foundation. It’s a good idea to let the mattress breathe and fully inflate for a couple days before sleeping on it.
Once the mattress is delivered, Puffy offers you a 101-night risk-free sleep trial. This is part of what makes shopping for a bed online so great. Basically, Puffy is giving you over three months to test their bed in the comfort of your own home (i.e. no annoying salesman standing over you) and decide whether you want to keep it. If you do, great. If you decide the Puffy mattress is not for you within the trial period, just contact customer support and they’ll take care of everything.
First, they’ll arrange for a third party service to come remove the mattress from your home for no additional charge. Once that occurs, just provide proof to Puffy that the mattress has indeed been picked up and they’ll issue you a refund in full. Next, Puffy backs their mattresses with a lifetime warranty. You can read more about it on the company’s website. Now, it’s important to note that Puffy goes above and beyond the typical industry standards. Most online beds come with free delivery, free returns, a 100-night trial period, and a 10-year warranty.
Nectar goes above and beyond, as well. The Nectar mattress ships for free. However, instead of arriving in a box, it actually arrives rolled up in a protective bag. We have heard a few complaints, though, about the Nectar mattress taking a long time to arrive. That didn’t happen to us, but we’d say to be safe expect it to take 2-3 weeks from time of purchase to delivery.
Nectar is one of the few companies out there that offers a 365-night trial period. Yes, the company gives you a full year to test the bed and decide whether you want to keep it. If you do decide to return it, the process works the same way as described above. Similar to Puffy, Nectar also backs their beds with a Forever Warranty. Again, it might be a good idea to read more about it on the company’s website. All in all, Puffy and Nectar offer some of the most consumer-friendly policies in the bedding industry.