Today we discuss the big reasons to pay up for Tuft & Needle Mint and also the reasons why you might want to save money and get the original mattress. If you aren’t familiar, Tuft & Needle is largely considered the best budget mattress brand.
It’s also one of the most popular bed-in-a-box mattress brands online, making it an easy choice for shoppers who want a safe, comfortable mattress. What might be a little less easy is comparing how two beds from Tuft & Needle is right for you. Our Tuft & Needle Original vs. Tuft & Needle Mint review will cover everything you need to know. Here are the top differences at a glance:
- Construction — The Original mattress has two layers and the Mint has three.
- Firmness — Differences between Tuft & Needle Mint vs Tuft & Needle Original also come down to how firm they are. The Mint model is a tad softer than the original, making it best for side sleepers.
- Price — The Original mattress is a well-priced entry-level mattress and the Mint is an upgraded version that will cost you more.
|$745 – $1,395||Price Range||$645 – $1,095|
|Check Current Offers||Offer||Check Current Offers|
|100 Nights||Trial Period||100 Nights|
|10 Years||Warranty||10 Years|
|Free Shipping and Returns||Shipping Options||Free Shipping and Returns|
|Shop Now||Shop Now|
Tuft & Needle Original vs. Mint Video
Tuft & Needle vs. Mint Mattress Construction and Design
Tuft & Needle Original has a very simple design. The original bed is 10″ thick and has two layers:
- Base layer — A dense support core
- Comfort layer — A T&N Adaptive Foam graphite-infused comfort layer
While the original bed has a two-layer 10″ construction, Mint has a three-layer 12″ construction. As a result, it’s more durable and more supportive.
- Support layer — Dense polyurethane foam support core
- Transition layer — T&N Adaptive Foam comfort layer
- Comfort layer — Comfort foam layer with 30% more graphite to help with temperature regulation
Tuft & Needle Mint vs. Original Feel and Firmness
The original bed has a plain Jane, neutral-foam feel, while the Mint is more soft and plush. If you can just envision a generic foam that’s soft, but not too soft, that’s what the original bed feels like. As our graphic shows, we estimate that the original bed is close to a medium in terms of firmness.
Because of the updated design, the Mint will be noticeably softer than the original bed. We have the Mint at somewhere between a medium-soft and medium on our firmness spectrum. This is a relative measure and will depend on your shape and weight, but for most people, the Mint will be a truly soft and plush mattress.
- Side sleepersGood For
Because it’s so soft, Tuft & Needle Mint is a wonderful solution for side sleepers who need maximum pressure relief, particularly for their hips, shoulders, or upper back. We picked it as part of our Best Mattresses for Side Sleepers list.
- Combination sleepers
Don’t let the simplicity of the original mattress fool you — Tuft & Needle is comfortable and versatile in the sense that it will work for a lot of sleeping styles, making it just right for combination sleepers.
- Back and stomach sleepers
The Mint is the type of mattress that you lay on and immediately experience pressure relief. It’s ideal for back and stomach sleepers unless you’re heavier and sink too far in the foam.
Because the original bed is firmer, it makes sense for it to be more ideal for back and stomach sleepers — and that is indeed the case.
Tuft & Needle vs. Mint Pricing
While we don’t think you should base your decision solely on price, there is a big price difference between the original and Mint that you can’t ignore. The original sells for about $900, and the Mint sells for about $1,200 for a queen-size bed. That’s absent any discounts or promotions.
|Size||Tuft & Needle Original||Tuft & Needle Mint|
Aside from construction, firmness, and price, here are a few other mattress attributes you should be thinking about. Especially if you sleep with a partner.
This refers to how supportive the perimeter of the mattress is. The edge support is better on the Mint mattress than Tuft & Needle Original because they reinforced the first layer with extra firm foam around the edges. With that being said, it’s good, but not phenomenal.
Both the Mint model and Original are great at isolating motion because their all-foam constructions are great at absorbing motion. If your partner tends to get up from bed often in the middle of the night, either mattress will work just fine at deadening movement.
Neither the Tuft & Needle Mint nor the Original have cooling abilities that make them cooling mattresses. They shouldn’t make you sleep hot, but they won’t help you sleep cold either. Though, the Mint model is slightly better at regulating temperature because of its graphite-infused design which draws body heat away from you.
Tuft & Needle Original vs. Mint Mattress Review Verdict
We cannot tell you what to do, but we can help to guide you in the right direction. With that in mind, here’s a quick recap of the things that you should be thinking about with Tuft & Needle Mint vs Tuft & Needle Original.
- Do you need a cheap mattress? If that’s the case, I suppose both beds will work, but the original is quite a bit more affordable when it’s all said and done.
- Do you sleep on your side? If you prefer a softer mattress because you sleep on your side, Tuft & Needle Mint is the best option!
- Are you a back or stomach sleeper? The Original Tuft & Needle will likely be the better option, especially if you’re more petite.
The truth is that a lot of your decision will come down to feel, firmness, and price. You can always check out our other mattress comparisons for additional context on how these beds compare to others.
Other Tuft & Needle products
Tuft & Needle mattress ratings
- BBB Rating: A+
- Amazon Reviews: Customers give Tuft & Needle a 4.3 out of 5, with good customer value and comfort as the positives and a poor return process as the main complaint.
Why Trust Us
Get the kind of sleep you’ve only dreamed of with some help from our team of mattress experts. We personally test more than 175 of the best sleep solutions from over 60 leading brands on-site, so you can be sure you’re getting unbiased reviews, fair comparisons, and personalized recommendations.
The Review Team
You can sleep on your new mattress as soon as you unpack it but Tuft & Needle recommends letting the mattress expand one or two hours before sleeping on it.
The Mint has an added top layer and built-in edge support, making it better if you’re heavier-weight. However, heavier people will get more out of a bed with coils.
The Mint mattress has 30% more graphite in the comfort layer, making it cooler to sleep on. However, both of them sleep temperature neutral.
Try a T&N mattress for 100 nights. If you’re not happy, contact customer service to return it.
It’ll likely be worth it for sleepers who want a softer profile with a little more durability than the 2-layer Tuft & Needle Original. However, if you sleep on your back, stomach, or weigh over 230 pounds, you should look for a firmer and more supportive bed.
Yes, after testing Tuft & Needle Mint our team found it was softer than the original Tuft & Needle, coming in around a medium to medium-soft on our scale.