Tuft and Needle vs Casper Mattress
These are two of the top bed in a box mattresses, but which is better—Casper or Tuft & Needle?
Last Updated: July 29, 2020
Casper and Tuft & Needle were two of the early pioneers in the online mattress industry and have since achieved tremendous success. In this post, we’ll break down the pros and cons of each bed so you can gain a better of understanding of which mattress is best for your particular sleeping habits.
|AT A GLANCE||PRICING||HEADLINE|
|Soft Foam||$100 Off Code: SLUMBERYARD||Casper Original is the mattress that started it all. If you just want a comfortable foam mattress, it’s hard to do better than Casper.|
|Soft Foam||15% Off Discount In Cart||Tuft & Needle is quite possibly the most popular budget mattress online. The bed is comfortable and accommodates all types of sleepers.|
Casper Mattress vs. Tuft & Needle – Synopsis
Two factors can explain the primary differences between these two beds:
- Price — Tuft & Needle is more affordable than the Original Casper.
- Side Sleepers — The original Casper mattress is more accommodating for people that spend a lot of time on their side.
Those are just the two main points, though. Of course, there are more details about each bed you should know. Keep reading to learn more.
Above are a few jump-to links to help you get around this comparison quickly. We made sure to include comparison sections for the brands’ other models as well.
Tuft & Needle and the original Casper are alike in a lot of ways. They’re both all-foam beds that have similar feels and perform well in almost all categories. Nevertheless, we’ll do our best to point out differences.
The original Casper mattress (the company also offers the Element and the Wave) has three layers. Casper also released two hybrid models called Casper Hybrid and Wave Hybrid. When we say a hybrid mattress, it means the bed incorporates a blend of foam and coils.
Design Of The Original Casper
The Casper mattress starts with a dense layer of support foam on the bottom. On top of that is what Casper calls its Zoned Support Foam.
This layer is split into thirds and is new to the Casper mattress. The portions where you need more pressure relief (under your shoulders and legs) are softer, while the areas where you need more support (under your trunk and lower back) are firmer.
On top of the Zoned Support Foam is a layer of memory foam and then a layer of open-cell proprietary foam. Like Tuft & Needle, the proprietary foam on top gives the mattress more of a soft neutral-foam feel, as opposed to a memory foam feel.
The Casper bed doesn’t contour or hug your body the way true memory foam does. We like that. We think Casper is an extremely comfortable bed.
In terms of firmness, we’d say the Casper mattress comes in around a medium on the firmness scale. It’s softer and more accommodating than the Tuft & Needle right out of the box. The bed finds a balance between comfort, pressure relief and support.
As such, we think all types of sleepers will enjoy this bed.
However, given it is only an 11″ all-foam mattress, we’d say this bed and Tuft & Needle is better for petite and average-sized body types. Heavy sleepers who weigh more than 250 lbs will be better off going with a thicker all-foam bed or, better yet, with a mattress that contains coils such as the new Casper Hybrid or Wave Hybrid.
Casper Mattress Pros And Cons
- The three-zone support framework gives better comfort.
- It has minimal off-gassing odor.
- It expands when out of the box in minutes.
- Casper is more expensive.
- Customers sometimes claim there are inconsistent mattress sizes.
- The neutral foam may not provide enough support for larger individuals.
Other Casper Products
Casper Mattress Reviews
- BBB rating: A+
- Amazon reviews: The Casper sleeps cool and is supportive for all sleeping types, but it does have some odor at the beginning. Some people also complained about poor customer service.
Another similarity Casper vs. Tuft share is both beds are temperature neutral. You won’t heat up and start sweating on either bed, but they also won’t actively keep you cool. If you’re a hot sleeper and concerned about staying cool, we’d recommend checking out our Best Cooling Mattresses list.
Similarities Between Casper And Tuft And Needle
Casper and Tuft & Needle are both viable options for couples. They’re both all-foam beds, so they do a good job of limiting motion transfer. That’s important for couples with one partner who tends to move around a lot throughout the night. If that happens on these beds, the other person won’t be disturbed and will be able to enjoy a more peaceful night of sleep.
These two beds also provide decent edge support. A hybrid or innerspring bed would probably be better in this department, but both Casper and Tuft & Needle hold their own. There’s little compression around the edges, and you don’t get feel like you’ll roll off the side.
All in all, we like the Casper mattress a lot. There’s a reason why the company has done so well—it makes a darn good bed. It’s extremely comfortable and accommodates almost all sleepers types and body sizes.
However, it’s more expensive than Tuft & Needle.
Casper Element vs. Tuft And Needle
Casper Element is Casper’s version of T&N. It used to be called the Essential. The Element is an uber-affordable mattress that’s great for college students, guest rooms and kids.
The quick story is that Casper Element and T&N are around the same price, but there are subtle differences that might get you to purchase one over the other. We don’t have a winner because we consider them to be so comparable.
Casper Element is a 10″ thick mattress that features three layers of foam. It’s slightly thicker than Tuft and Needle. Aside from that, the retail price is similar when you discuss Casper Element vs. Tuft & Needle.
We might, however, rate Casper Element a little firmer than Tuft & Needle. Therefore, for strict side sleepers, our preference between the two would likely be Tuft & Needle. However, we have to split hairs with these two beds to crown a winner.
Let’s just quickly review what Tuft and Needle and Casper have in common:
Both mattresses have a soft neutral-foam feel. You won’t get that stuck-in-the-mud feeling with either, and we think the majority of people will find both beds comfortable.
Tuft & Needle and Casper both sleep temperature neutral. The beds are not cool to the touch and won’t actively cool you down. However, you won’t wake up in a puddle of your own sweat either.
There are only a handful of beds we’ve tested that deserve the “cooling” designation.
SEE ALSO: Best Mattresses for Hot Sleepers
Both mattresses deaden movement well and provide decent edge support. Both beds are solid options for couples who share a bed (especially a smaller size like a full or queen).
Differences: Casper vs. Tuft And Needle
Now let’s talk about how Tuft & Needle is different than Casper. First is the price. Tuft & Needle is much cheaper, and it’s known as “THE” budget bed-in-a-box. You can snag a queen-size for around $600.
Casper offers a queen-size (after discount) for around $1,000. That’s a difference of about $400. That said, Casper is fairly aggressive with its discounts, especially during holidays.
Inside The Original T&N Mattress
How can Tuft & Needle afford to price its bed that way? The reason probably has to do with the construction and cost of materials.
The original Casper mattress uses three layers (Casper’s new hybrid beads will contain more), including the new Zoned Support layer. The Tuft & Needle mattress uses two layers. There’s a dense layer of support foam on the bottom and a softer proprietary (called T&N Adaptive Foam) on top.
The Tuft & Needle mattress is firmer than the Casper mattress right out of the box, probably because Casper uses two transition layers from bottom to top, whereas Tuft & Needle does not.
As such, we think the T&N mattress is best for back, stomach and combo sleepers at first. However, the foam will soften over time. That means side sleepers will find the bed becomes more accommodating for their hips and shoulders over time.
SEE ALSO: Best Mattresses for Side Sleepers
We’d go with the Casper mattress all things considered, but it’s tough to argue with the pricing of Tuft & Needle.
Tuft And Needle Mint vs. Casper
Tuft & Needle Mint is the premium, upgraded foam mattress from T&N. It’s around the same price as Casper but is softer. They retail for a similar price, so it’s no wonder why people want to know who wins when discussing Tuft and Needle Mint vs. Casper.
We don’t have a winner for this comparison. We think Casper is a little more accommodating for stomach and back sleepers, while Tuft and Needle Mint is probably better for side sleepers concerned with pressure relief. Even so, Casper is a fantastic mattress for side sleepers.
In conclusion, here are the main things to keep in mind:
Tuft & Needle Mint — This is a softer mattress with a neutral feel, similar to that of Casper. It’s better for someone who wants a soft mattress.
Casper — The “original” online mattress, Casper is as accommodating as possible. It’s firmer than Tuft & Needle Mint, but that’s to accommodate stomach and back sleepers in addition to side sleepers.
Casper vs. Tuft And Needle Hybrid
In late 2019, Tuft & Needle launched its first hybrid mattress.
It’s difficult to say one bed is better than the other one. Casper and Tuft & Needle are popular and accommodating. Everything comes down to a few smaller points.
Tuft & Needle Hybrid is the first T&N mattress to feature a slight memory foam feel. Tuft & Needle beds usually have a neutral, soft foam. That’s somewhat true of Tuft & Needle Hybrid, but it has more of a memory foam feel than Casper Hybrid.
Tuft & Needle Hybrid also has the micro-springs under the top foam layer in addition to the support coils at the bottom. You won’t be able to notice they exist, but they’re designed to provide bi-directional support at a more localized level. Casper Hybrid, in contrast, has one layer of pocketed coils.
Tuft And Needle Pros and Cons
- Breathable cover
- Adaptable gel and foam top layer for a cooler sleeping experience
- Worse edge support than Casper
- Mattress may be too firm for some customers
- No integrated handles to move the mattress easier
Other Tuft And Needle products
Tuft And Needle Mattress Reviews
- BBB rating: A+
- Amazon reviews: Reviewers noticed that the company has excellent customer service and offers an excellent price-to-quality ratio. People say the bed is supportive in several sleep positions, but some side sleepers say it’s a little too firm.
Which one should I buy?
In a Tuft vs. Casper price showdown, Tuft & Needle beats Casper on price. You’ll save between $245 and $545 off the MSRP on all Tuft & Needle mattress sizes.
Casper vs. Tuft And Needle
|Size||Casper||Tuft & Needle|
Mattress Comparison Verdict
Tuft & Needle and Casper are similar, so we can see why it’s hard to decide between the two. To make the decision easier, ask yourself two questions.
First, what kind of budget do you have? If it’s a tight budget, Tuft & Needle is the clear winner. If money isn’t an issue, we’d say go with Casper.
Next, how much time do you spend on your side? If the answer is more than 50-60 percent, Casper would be the better choice.
In a Tuft vs. Casper comparison, Tuft & Needle beats Casper in value. You’ll save $500 on a queen mattress and $545 on the king size. Don’t mistake the price for compromising on quality — Tuft & Needle’s mattresses are comparable in quality, guarantee and trial period to Casper’s.
You can sleep right away on both mattress styles. They take a few minutes to expand. Tuft & Needle recommends leaving the mattress alone for one or two hours before sleeping on it, which would be advisable for either mattress.
The Casper and Tuft & Needle are both designed to be breathable. Tuft features an adaptable gel and foam top layer with a breathable cover for heat dissipation. Casper’s top layer is latex foam for better airflow.