Casper and Tuft & Needle were two of the early pioneers in the online mattress industry and have since achieved tremendous success. In this post, we'll break down the pros and cons of each bed so you can gain a better of understanding of which mattress is best for your particular sleeping habits.

VS.
$595 – $1,295Price Range$450 – $850
15% Off Code: JULY4THOffer 10% Off Applied In Cart
  • People that are looking for a comfortable, affordable mattress
  • Anyone that’s interested in a bed-in-a-box mattress
Best For
  • Shoppers who want an affordable foam mattress
  • All types of sleepers, including back, stomach and side
100 NightsTrial Period100 Nights
10 YearsWarranty10 Years
Free Shipping and ReturnsShipping Options Free Shipping and Returns
Shop Now Shop Now

Tuft & Needle vs. Casper Mattress Overview

Tuft & Needle and the original Casper are alike in a lot of ways. They’re both all-foam beds that have similar feels and perform well in almost all categories, and both companies have reputations for making high-quality beds. If you’re choosing Tuft & Needle vs. Casper, it all comes down to your preference rather than quality or features for the most part.

Two factors can explain the primary differences between these beds:

  • Price — Tuft & Needle is more affordable than the original Casper.
  • Side sleepers — The original Casper mattress is more accommodating for people that spend a lot of time on their side.
  • Tuft & Needle vs. Casper Video Comparison

Design & Construction

Casper has a few varieties, but this review will focus on the original Casper, which has three layers:

  • Support layer — The Casper mattress starts with a dense layer of support foam on the bottom.
  • Zoned layer — Casper calls this layer its Zoned Support Foam. It’s split into thirds, so the portions where you need more pressure relief (under your shoulders and legs) are softer, while the areas where you need more support (under your trunk and lower back) are firmer.
  • Comfort layer — On top of the Zoned Support Foam is a layer of memory foam and then a layer of open-cell proprietary foam. Like Tuft & Needle, the proprietary foam on top gives the mattress more of a soft neutral-foam feel, as opposed to a memory foam feel.
casper original mattress review zoned support
The Zoned Support Foam on the Casper mattress is unique

How about Tuft & Needle compared to Casper? Like Casper, the Tuft & Needle bed is made from all foam, but it only has two layers:

  • Support layer — There’s a dense layer of support foam on the bottom.
  • Comfort layer — The bed has a softer proprietary (called T&N Adaptive Foam) on top.
tuft and needle mattress review construction and foam layers
A peek inside the Tuft & Needle mattress

Feel & Firmness

The Casper bed doesn’t contour or hug your body the way true memory foam does. We like that. We think Casper is an extremely comfortable bed.

In terms of firmness, we’d say the Casper mattress comes in around a medium on the firmness scale. It’s softer and more accommodating than the Tuft & Needle right out of the box. The bed finds a balance between comfort, pressure relief and support.

As such, we think all types of sleepers will enjoy this bed.

casper mattress review firmness rating

When it comes to the feel of the Tuft & Needle mattress vs. Casper, T&N has a neutral-foam feel that’s comfortable and accommodating. It’s highly responsive, meaning that it’s quick to snap back into place after you get off the bed (unlike memory foam).

As we mentioned, the Tuft & Needle mattress is slightly firmer than the Casper mattress right out of the box, probably because Casper uses more layers, including a softer transition layer, whereas Tuft & Needle does not. Still, it also earned around medium on our soft-to-firm scale.

Other Factors to Consider

If you share a bed with a partner, there are two major components to consider (in addition to the feel and firmness of your bed): edge support and motion isolation. Here’s how Casper vs. Tuft & Needle compare in these categories.

Edge Support

With Casper, you won’t feel like you’re going to roll off the bed if you get close to the edge. It’s a similar story with Tuft & Needle, but if you’re really concerned about edge support, we’d suggest getting a larger size.

Motion Transfer

All-foam beds generally do a good job of limiting cross-bed motion, so Casper does fine in this category. Tuft & Needle also scores well in terms of deadening movement, although it wouldn’t make our list of the best mattresses for light sleepers.

Temperature

Casper and Tuft & Needle are temperature-neutral beds. You won’t heat up and start sweating on either bed, but it also won’t actively keep you cool. If you’re a hot sleeper and concerned about staying cool, we’d recommend checking out our Best Cooling Mattresses list.

Body Type Analysis

Did you know that your weight plays a key role in how a bed feels to you? Find out how you’ll perceive Tuft & Needle vs. Casper mattress based on your weight category below. 

  • Petite

    Either Tuft & Needle or Casper will work for petite individuals (150 lbs or less). If you’re in this weight group, mattresses tend to feel firmer than they would to heavier people. However, both of these beds are comfortable and supportive enough for lighter folks.

  • Normal

    Average-sized people should be fine on most beds, including Casper and Tuft & Needle. You’ll get a good mix of pressure relief and support from either of these mattresses. Keep in mind that we write all of our reviews from this weight category’s point of view.

  • Heavy

    Heavy sleepers who weigh more than 250 lbs will be better off going with a mattress that contains coils, such as the new Casper Hybrid or Wave Hybrid (if you like Casper) or the Tuft & Needle hybrid (if you prefer T&N). Or, there are thicker foam beds out there that are more accommodating if you have your heart set on a foam mattress.

Sleeper Type Analysis

In addition to your body type, you should also factor in the way you sleep when picking out a mattress. Find out whether Tuft & Needle or Casper is best suited for your sleeper style.

  • Side Sleepers

    Both beds should be fine for most side sleepers, but they could be a bit firm if you’re petite. As the foam softens overtime on the Tuft & Needle, side sleepers will find the bed becomes more accommodating for their hips and shoulders.

  • Combo Sleepers

    If you switch between sleeping positions, you’re better off with a responsive bed, so you don’t struggle to move around. We found that both Casper and Tuft & Needle are suitable for these sleeper types.

  • Back And Stomach Sleepers

    Neither of these beds is the firmest, but we still think that back and sleepers should be fine on Casper or Tuft & Needle. Casper has its zoned support construction going for it, while Tuft and Needle is a tad bit firmer by design.

Casper Company Policies

  • Shipping — Free shipping
  • Trial period — 100 nights
  • Warranty —10 years

Other Casper Mattresses vs Tuft & Needle

  • Casper Element vs. Tuft And Needle

    Casper Element is an uber-affordable mattress that’s great for college students, guest rooms and kids. Casper Element is a 10″ thick mattress that features three layers of foam. It’s slightly thicker than Tuft and Needle.

    Casper Element and T&N are around the same price, but there are subtle differences that might get you to purchase one over the other. We don’t have a winner because we consider them to be so comparable.

    We might, however, rate Casper Element a little firmer than Tuft & Needle. Therefore, for strict side sleepers, our preference between the two would likely be Tuft & Needle.

Tuft & Needle Company Policies

  • Shipping — Free
  • Trial period — 100 nights
  • Warranty — 10 years

Other Tuft & Needle Mattresses vs. Casper

  • Tuft & Needle Mint vs. Casper

    Tuft & Needle Mint is the premium, upgraded foam mattress from T&N. It’s around the same price as Casper but is softer. They retail for a similar price, so it’s no wonder why people want to know who wins when discussing Tuft and Needle Mint vs. Casper.

    We think Casper is a little more accommodating for stomach and back sleepers, while Tuft & Needle Mint is probably better for side sleepers concerned with pressure relief. Even so, Casper is a fantastic mattress for side sleepers.

Tuft & Needle vs Casper Pricing

Tuft & Needle is much cheaper, and it’s known as “THE” budget bed-in-a-box. You can snag a queen-size for around $600. Casper offers a queen-size (after discount) for around $1,100. That’s a difference of about $500. That said, Casper is fairly aggressive with its discounts, especially during holidays.

SIZECASPER PRICE (MSRP)TUFT & NEEDLE PRICE (MSRP)
Twin$595$450
Twin XL$695$495
Full$995$595
Queen$1,095$695
King / California King$1,295$850

Casper Mattress vs Tuft & Needle Mattress Review Verdict

Tuft & Needle and Casper are similar, so we can see why it’s hard to decide between the two. To make the decision easier, ask yourself two questions:

  • First, what kind of budget do you have? If it’s a tight budget, Tuft & Needle is the clear winner. If money isn’t an issue, we’d say go with Casper.
  • How much time do you spend on your side? If the answer is more than 50-60 percent, Casper would be the better choice.
why trust us icon

Why Trust Us

Get the kind of sleep you’ve only dreamed of with some help from our team of mattress experts. We personally test more than 150 of the best sleep solutions from over 60 leading brands on site, so you can be sure you’re getting unbiased reviews, fair comparisons and personalized recommendations.


The Review Team

  • Dillon Payne

    Combo Sleeper

  • dillon lopez slumber yard

    Dillon Lopez

    Combo Sleeper

  • kenzie

    McKenzie Dillon

    Combo Sleeper

  • Jeff Rizzo

    Jeff Rizzo

    Combo Sleeper

Frequently Asked Questions
When comparing Casper vs. Tuft and Needle, which one’s more affordable?
In a Tuft vs. Casper comparison, Tuft & Needle beats Casper in value. You’ll save $500 on a queen mattress and $545 on the king size. Don’t mistake the price for compromising on quality — Tuft & Needle’s mattresses are comparable in quality, guarantee and trial period to Casper’s.
How soon can you sleep on a Casper vs. Tuft Mattress?
You can sleep right away on both mattress styles. They take a few minutes to expand. Tuft & Needle recommends leaving the mattress alone for two to three hours before sleeping on it, which would be advisable for either mattress.
Which mattress sleeps cooler?
The Casper and Tuft & Needle are both designed to be breathable. Tuft features an adaptable gel and foam top layer with a breathable cover for heat dissipation. Casper’s top layer is latex foam for better airflow.