The market for bed-in-a-box mattresses has become increasingly crowded, with hundreds of online bedding brands. While it’s great you have so many options to choose from, it can be overwhelming if you don’t know exactly what you want or where to start.
We’ve put together a shortlist of options of best bed-in-a-boxes to narrow down the pool for you. Each was hand-picked by our team of mattress experts who have tested over 175 mattresses (and counting). The beds that made their way onto our list are either top-rated, offer a fantastic value, or are made from one-of-a-kind materials.
Additionally, it’s worth mentioning we tried to keep the queen size mattress around the $1,000 mark after discounts. Obviously, this criteria eliminates many great box mattresses, so if you’re not constrained to a particular dollar figure, you may want to check out our Best Luxury Mattress list.
Top 10 Mattresses-in-a-Box
- Best Value for Mattress-in-a-Box :NectarStarting at $798 Shop Now
- Editor’s Choice :Brooklyn Bedding SignatureStarting at $599 Shop Now
- Best Memory Foam Mattress-in-a-Box :LaylaStarting at $749 Shop Now
- Best Hybrid Mattress-in-a-Box :Bear HybridStarting at $1095 Shop Now
- Best Organic Mattress-in-a-Box :Avocado Green MattressStarting at $1099 Shop Now
- Best Foam Mattress-in-a-Box :Casper OriginalStarting at $695 Shop Now
- Best Mattress-in-a-Box for Hot Sleepers :Purple OriginalStarting at $699 Shop Now
- Best Luxury Mattress-in-a-Box :WinkBeds ClassicStarting at $1149 Shop Now
- Most Accommodating Mattress-in-a-Box :Helix MidnightStarting at $699 Shop Now
- Best Mattress-in-a-Box For Heavy People :TitanStarting at $699 Shop Now
Honest Best Bed In A Box Video Review
Swipe to see why these made our list
Swipe to see why these made our list
Why We Chose These Mattresses
Below, we explain why we think these bed-in-a-box mattresses are among the best, and who we think they suit most. The beds that made their way onto our list are either top-rated, offer an amazing value, or are made from one-of-a-kind materials. Additionally, it’s worth mentioning we tried to keep the queen size mattress around the $1,000 mark after discounts. Obviously, this criteria eliminates a lot of great box mattresses, so if you’re not constrained to a particular dollar figure you may want to check out our Best Luxury Mattress list.
Compare the Best Mattresses-in-a-Box
BEST VALUE FOR A MATTRESS-IN-A-BOX
Nectar could be the most popular memory foam mattress online. It’s affordable, comfortable, and usually comes with free pillows. They also have monthly payment options with Affirm.
Why Nectar wins as the best value for a mattress-in-a-box
Nectar has a firmness profile that suits most sleeper types and conforming memory foam feel for a price that’s way more affordable than a TempurPedic Mattress. It’s one of the most popular wallet-friendly memory foam beds in a box.
If you like memory foam, you’ll probably love Nectar. It has a dense memory foam feel, and as such, it’s somewhat slow in terms of responsiveness. This means there’ll be a bit of resistance as you rotate between sleeping positions at night and might not be a good fit for active sleepers. If you don’t like memory foam, you will not like Nectar.
Nectar’s best features
- It’s about medium to medium-firm in terms of overall firmness, which is a good compromise between support and pressure relief.
- Nectar has a machine-washable cooling cover. The material feels cool to the touch and wicks away the heat. The combination of the cooling cover, the gel memory foam and the firmness profile makes Nectar temperature neutral. This is unusual for traditional memory foam mattresses.
- Nectar often includes free pillows with your purchase.
Brooklyn Bedding Signature is one of the best online mattresses for the money. It has pocketed coils, is made in the USA, and comes in three firmness options. It also sells for far less than you’d expect.
Why Brooklyn Bedding Signature wins as Editor’s Choice
The Brooklyn Signature mattress is an innerspring bed-in-a-box mattress with a quilted top layer. Hybrid mattresses tend to be more expensive because they are more durable and made with supportive materials. Brooklyn Bedding Signature, however, offers long-lasting comfort and support for all body types at a really great price.
It’s an accommodating bed that will work for any sleeper type (back, stomach, side, combo) and all body types (petite, medium, heavy). We also like that the company doesn’t outsource manufacturing—it makes the mattresses in Phoenix, AZ.
Brooklyn Bedding Signature’s best features
- You can choose between three firmness levels (soft, medium, and firm) to best match your sleep style and comfort preferences.
- It’s hybrid construction makes it an ideal choice for all body types.
- The comfort layer uses TitanFlex foam, a proprietary hyper-elastic foam that is soft yet responsive.
- A queen-size Brooklyn Bedding Signature Mattress usually costs under $1,000, so you’re getting a nice mattress for your money.
BEST MEMORY FOAM MATTRESS-IN-A-BOX
Layla is a memory foam mattress that’s flippable and features a “Soft” and “Firm” side. If you like fluffy beds, you will probably like this one.
Why Layla wins as best memory foam mattress-in-a-box
Layla is one of the most versatile and interesting beds-in-a-box that you can buy. It has a “Soft” and a “Firm” side, which allows it to handle all sleeping positions. If you’re open to memory foam and want a fluffier bed, Layla is worth checking out, especially if you are a side sleeper.
Layla’s best features
- Layla has a super-soft cover that even identifies the “Soft” and “Firm” sides. There’s no need to remove the cover to switch firmness profiles—all you do is flip the bed.
- The bed is made with copper-infused memory foam to help regulate temperature.
- The Layla mattress comes with a lifetime warranty.
- It has a good price compared to its competitors. A queen-size Layla mattress will run you for about $1,100, but the company often offers promotions to bring that price down even more.
BEST HYBRID MATTRESS-IN-A-BOX
Bear Hybrid is a pillowtop mattress with a fluffy feel and pocketed coils for support. A bonus is that a 20-year warranty backs it.
Why Bear Hybrid wins as the best hybrid mattress-in-a-box
The Bear Hybrid is one of our favorite online beds; we even added it to our 2022 list of best mattresses. The medium firmness profile makes it comfortable for practically all types of sleepers, no matter their size. The improved coil system offers support and durability, while the soft, thick topper will make you feel like sleeping on pillows.
The Bear Hybrid also offers some luxurious features without being too expensive. The most recent improvements include switching micro coils for solid 8″ pocketed coils, which should provide more support for a longer time, especially for heavier people.
Bear Hybrid’s best features
- The Bear Hybrid mattress provides the support of a spring mattress with the plush feel of a pillowtop bed.
- The cover uses a Celliant material, which is supposed to help improve your sleep quality, among other health benefits.
- Bear Hybrid has one of the most difficult certifications to get for a bed in terms of environmental safety certifications, the GREENGUARD Gold Certified by the UL, on top of the more common CertiPUR-US.
BEST ORGANIC MATTRESS-IN-A-BOX
The Avocado Green Mattress is the most sought-after natural/organic mattress online. It’s supportive, comfortable, and constructed with high-quality materials.
Why Avocado wins as the best organic mattress-in-a-box
Avocado is the perfect mattress for anyone who wants a top-rated natural and organic mattress-in-a-box. It’s made with pocketed coils as its support system and certified organic Dunlop latex for an extra bouncy and supportive feel.
Overall, Avocado is a firm bed, better suited for back and stomach sleepers. That said, you have the option to add a pillow top. It does increase the price of the mattress but also makes the bed a little softer—about a “medium-firm.”
As such, it will work for back, stomach, and combo sleepers, but we wouldn’t consider it the best option for petite side sleepers. All in all, we think it’s a very comfortable mattress-in-a-box.
Avocado’s best features
- The company uses eco-friendly recycled steel for its coils, so they support you and the environment.
- The bed has a cover made of organic cotton, which is button-tufted by hand. It looks nice, is soft to the touch and smells kind of earthy.
- The Dunlop latex used in the comfort layer is naturally antimicrobial, making it great for people with allergies as it also prevents dust mites. And even better, the material is sustainably harvested from rubber trees.
BEST FOAM MATTRESS-IN-A-BOX
Casper Original is the mattress that started it all. If you just want a comfortable foam mattress, it’s hard to do better than Casper.
Why Casper wins as best foam mattress-in-a-box
How could we leave out THE bed-in-a-box mattress, Casper? They weren’t the first to come up with the online mattress shopping idea, but they played a role in making it more common. And for a good reason.
It’s a great bed, and we think most people who try it won’t end up returning it. Are you a side sleeper? It’ll work for you. Do you mainly sleep on your back? It’ll work for you. Combo? It’ll work for you. Casper has a neutral-foam feel and accommodating medium firmness level (a 5 out of 10 on our scale) that became the sweet spot for many online mattresses.
Casper’s best features
- We love the Casper bed’s zoned support framework. It has alternating firmness levels to accommodate different parts of your body.
- Casper has a pretty average price point and usually costs right under $1,000 for a queen after discounts.
- Casper feels like a soft foam but without the stuck-in-the-mud feel of memory foam.
- The top layer uses an open-cell foam material that promotes better airflow for a temperature-neutral bed.
Why Purple wins as the best mattress-in-a-box for hot sleepers
The Purple mattress doesn’t feel like any other mattress you’ve tried before. Purple incorporates a supportive yet pressure-relieving material that no other mattress brand in history has ever used. Not only is Hyper-Elastic Polymer unique, but it’s also incredibly comfortable for all sleeper types and is great for people who tend to warm up at night.
It also happens to be surprisingly efficient at limiting motion transfer and is responsive, which means no stuck-in-the-mud feeling. Purple is one of the most breathable mattresses we’ve tested here at the Slumber Yard.
Full disclosure, some people love the unique gel-like feeling of this bed, while others have a hard time with it. If you decide to go with a Purple mattress, it may take a while to get used to how different it feels from your typical bed.
Purple’s best features
- The Purple mattress has a medium firmness profile that we think will be suitable for all types of sleepers (back, stomach, side, and combo).
- Heavier folks (over 220 lbs) should consider Purple’s new hybrid beds with coils.
- On top of the Hyper-Elastic Polymer layer is the “SoftFlex” cover, which is not only soft and stretchy but also breathable, so it won’t make you hot.
- Purple might not run discount deals often, but most of the time will include free items, like pillows or sheets when you purchase a mattress.
BEST LUXURY MATTRESS-IN-A-BOX
Winkbeds flagship model is a premium, durable bed that is also very comfortable. The company also makes a memory foam bed and an organic/natural model. But, bottom line, they all look and feel like they belong in a high-end hotel.
Why WinkBeds wins as the best luxury mattress-in-a-box
WinkBeds mattresses look expensive and offer options to satisfy the needs of most sleepers, including those with an interest in natural materials. Heavier sleepers can also find a supportive bed that can last for a long time without losing height or sagging.
The flagship WinkBeds model is a 15″ hybrid bed with a Euro pillow top. This is one of the thickest mattresses we’ve tested and something that should add to the product’s durability. The all-foam claims to use a proprietary memory foam technology that allows for better airflow and a lot of pressure relief. Meanwhile, the organic EcoCloud combines Talalay latex, organic cotton, and sustainable New Zealand wool for a naturally luxurious feel.
WinkBeds’ best features
- Winkbeds uses Tencel for the cover of the flagship and the GravityLux mattresses. Tencel is a material derived from the Eucalyptus tree that is soft to the touch and helps regulate temperature.
- You can choose your desired firmness level on the Winkbeds flagship and GravityLux models. The former has four firmness profiles, including one for heavier folks, and the GravityLux offers three options. The EcoCloud only has one, which is around a medium-firm.
MOST ACCOMMODATING MATTRESS-IN-A-BOX
Helix makes over ten different mattresses, practically one for every kind of sleeper you could find. Recognizing that it can be overwhelming for shoppers, it offers a sleep quiz to help you find the right bed for you.
Why Helix Sleep wins as the most accommodating mattress-in-a-box
Helix is a great place to start your mattress hunt if you’re unsure what you’re looking for. Rather than offer just one mattress model, Helix makes over 10. You’ll find six-core models, a luxe version of each of those core models, Helix Plus for heavier people, and the Birch mattress for a natural/organic option.
We think the amount of choices allows the customer to find a mattress for their specific needs. Using a sleep quiz to help identify the ideal product for you is an exciting concept in the online beds market.
Helix’s best features
- Thanks to the wide variety of models, you have multiple firmness options to pick from. The core and Luxe models come in “Soft,” “Medium” and “Firm” profiles; the Helix Plus is around a medium, while the Birch mattress is more of a medium-firm.
- Each core model has a Luxe version, which has a 2″ pillow top that brings the total height of the mattress to 14″.
BEST MATTRESS-IN-A-BOX FOR HEAVY PEOPLE
Titan is a solid mattress built to support heavier bodies, and it does it well. The bed is a great choice for people over 250 lbs who want a bed that will last a very long time.
Why Titan wins as the best mattress-in-a-box for heavy people
Brooklyn Bedding is known for its quality mattresses at affordable prices, and the Titan doesn’t disappoint. Brooklyn Bedding’s Titan is one of the firmest mattresses we’ve tested. The Titan Firm has a neutral foam feel, while the Luxe model feels more like a plush, pillow-top mattress. All in all, they’re both hybrid beds that do a great job of supporting all types of bodies.
The Titan bed from Brooklyn Bedding is built to support plus-sized bodies long-term without losing its form. And after discounts, you can get a Titan queen mattress for less than $1,000.
Titan’s best features
- The support layer of the Titan bed is made of what the company calls Titan Caliber coils, which are supposed to provide “industrial support” and optimal motion isolation.
- Titan’s foam layers aim to provide pressure relief, but the Titan Firm can be too firm for side and combo sleepers.
- If you tend to warm up during the night, you can purchase an optional cooling top panel, which paired with a firmer bed should help with temperature regulation while you sleep.
What’s a Bed-in-a-Box?
What’s a mattress-in-a-box? Well, it’s exactly how it sounds, a mattress that is compressed in plastic and rolled up to fit into a box that can ship easily. The pioneers used to be all-foam beds, but nowadays, you can buy online mattresses with coils and different materials.
If you are asking yourself, “is a mattress-in-a-box any good?” Well, that depends on the materials and what you’re looking for. You can find great options at different price points. Memory foam beds may go bad faster, but coil mattresses will last just the same as those found in brick and mortar stores, and latex beds could last up to 15 years.
Benefits of buying an online mattress
The main advantage of shopping online is convenience. You have all the options in front of you and you dodge the pressure of salespeople to purchase the spot.
Sure, you don’t get to test the mattress before buying it, but most brands give you plenty of time to try it out at home and return it if you don’t like what you picked. Most brands offer free shipping and returns and substantial warranties, which we think make up for not getting to try the beds beforehand.
- Easier comparison
We get it; a new mattress is an important decision. It may be a significant investment, and you’ll probably intend to keep it for at least eight years. Shopping online gives you the chance to compare as many beds as you want from your computer or mobile device. Besides the brands’ own website, you can read expert reviews and even reviews directly from customers. Some brands, like Helix, even provide comparison tools based on your needs or preferences to help you get customized recommendations.
- Better pricing
Another thing in favor of online mattresses is that you can probably get a better deal. By streamlining the sales process, they eliminate the intermediaries and can offer relatively lower prices. Some bed-in-a-box companies even have their own factories, translating into lower prices or deeper discounts. Not to mention the sales that are running essentially year-round.
How To Decide Which Bed You Should Buy
By sleeper type
People primarily sleep in three different positions—side, back, and stomach. Research shows that the most popular is side sleeping, while according to doctors and chiropractors, sleeping on your stomach is not preferable.
- Stomach Sleepers
If you like sleeping on your stomach, look for a firmer mattress. Like back sleepers, you want a bed-in-a-box mattress that can support your mid-section properly. However, it probably is preferable to consider mattresses that are a tad bit softer than the mattresses you’d consider for back sleeping.
- Back Sleepers
- Side Sleepers
People who spend a lot of time on their side will generally want a mattress on the softer side of the spectrum. Because all your weight will be directed toward two areas (your hip and shoulder of the side you’re laying on), those two areas must receive pressure relief. Again, you don’t want the mattress to be so soft to where you’re sinking in so far your spine is no longer properly aligned.
- Combo Sleepers
People who rotate between positions throughout the night will want to find a happy medium. You want to find a mattress that provides a good amount of support when you’re on your back or stomach and enough pressure relief when you switch to your side. That means you’ll probably be looking at a mattress in the medium-soft to medium-firm range on the firmness scale, depending on your percentage split between the different sleeping positions.
Your body type matters
Your weight and physical constitution will influence your mattress choice. The more you weigh, the more pressure you put on the mattress and the softer it will feel. So a bed that may be too firm for a petite person may feel more like a medium-firm to someone bigger. And the opposite is also true; a soft bed could be too soft for plus-size sleepers and cause them to sink too deep for comfort.
Heavier people should also consider mattresses with a coil support structure, as they’ll hold their form better and last longer than all-foam beds under more pressure.
Firmness levels recommended for your body
|Body type||Soft||Medium Soft||Medium||Medium Firm||Firm|
Materials and construction
The feel of a mattress is subjective. Again, there’s no right or wrong. It all comes down to personal preference. Each foam has a different type of feel and will attract different kinds of sleepers.
- Memory foam
This type of foam can have a very dense feel. When you lay down on a memory foam bed, you sort of slowly sink into it. Some people really like that feeling. They say it feels like the mattress is hugging them a little bit. The memory foam contours to your body and offers a ton of pressure relief for your pressure points (i.e., hips, shoulders). Other people say it gives them more of a stuck-in-the-mud feeling.
- Latex foam
Latex foam is lighter and airier than memory foam. As such, it has more of a neutral, soft foam feel. You won’t slowly sink into the foam as you do with memory foam. It’s also much more responsive and bouncy than memory foam.
That means latex foam beds won’t contour to your body as much, but they typically stay much cooler than memory foam or polyfoam. Latex can also be a natural/organic material in many cases (synthetic latex is less commonly used), whereas polyfoam is a petro-chemical product.
- Polyurethane foam
Most companies won’t use polyurethane foam for their top layer, so you’ll never really experience the authentic feel of it. Polyfoam is more used for support and transition layers. It tends to be denser and offers better support than memory foam and latex foam.
- Proprietary Foam
A lot of bed-in-a-box companies create their own foams. For example, Brooklyn Bedding uses a foam called “TitanFlex Comfort Foam.” Tuft & Needle uses a foam called “T&N Adaptive Foam.” Each foam is different, so it’s hard to pinpoint an exact feel, but they generally have a neutral, soft foam feel.
The feel of coil beds can vary quite a bit. As a result of the coils, the beds will be pretty responsive and have a little bounce. However, the feel of a coil mattress is largely dependent on its top layers.
Coil beds like DreamCloud that incorporate memory foam on top will have a soft, dense foam feel. On the other hand, an innerspring bed like the Brooklyn Bedding Bowery, which uses a proprietary foam top layer, will have a lighter, neutral-foam feel. Spring mattresses are more durable thanks to the extra support, and we recommend them especially for heavier folks.
Other Things To Consider When Buying a Bed-in-a-Box
Shipping, Returns and Warranties
Almost all bed-in-a-box mattress companies offer free shipping whether the bed comes in a box, in a protective covering, or via white glove delivery (i.e., an actual person helps you set up the bed). You’ll typically also receive a risk-free trial, free returns, and a generous warranty policy around ten years or more.
- Temperature Regulation
Typically, heavier individuals tend to heat up during the night more so than lighter individuals. A lot of that is because heavier body types sink further into a mattress, creating more of a hugging friction with the bed. But then there are people who just naturally sleep hot or cool (e.g., the person who always wears a sweatshirt and sweatpants to bed or the person who refuses to wear anything but underwear).
Sinkage is another critical factor for multiple reasons. A bed with a lot of sinkage can also be an early indicator of durability. Sometimes, with beds with a lot of sinkage, permanent body impressions will form quickly, compromising the integrity of the mattress. Sinkage is vital for heavier folks (235 lbs or over). Heavier people place more stress and pressure on a bed that can exacerbate sinkage issues even further.
If you sink too far into the bed, your spine will not be aligned correctly. That can result in back pain or stiffness when you wake up.
When we talk about responsiveness, we’re talking about how quickly the mattress pops back to its original form after releasing pressure. A responsive bed means you’ll find it much easier to switch between sleeping positions. With beds that aren’t as responsive, you’ll get a little bit of that stuck-in-the-mud feeling and find it requires a little extra effort to move, possibly making you more restless throughout the night.
Responsiveness can also serve as an indicator of how durable the mattress will be over the long haul. Sometimes with non-responsive beds, permanent body impressions can form in the mattress.
- Motion Transfer
Chances are you’ve probably heard of motion transfer before. This is largely for people who share a bed. When one person turns over or gets up, and the other person feels the bed reacting to this change, it can make for a restless night. Therefore, if you share a bed, you’ll want a mattress that can deaden movement well.
- Edge Support
Often, with partners who share a bed, one person will hog the middle of the bed, leaving the other person trapped on one of the edges. As such, the edges of your mattress must be able to support you. With a lot of mattresses (especially all-foam mattresses), you’ll get compression near the edges, making you feel like you’re about to roll off the bed. Obviously, this is not a good thing.
A lot of mattress companies in recent years have taken steps to correct this issue. For example, Purple mattresses incorporated a dense foam perimeter around all their coil mattresses that they introduced in 2018.
How We Select The Best Mattresses
- My Slumber Yard
The Slumber Yard has been around since the beginning of the bed-in-a-box craze. Our team has personally tested over 175 mattresses so far, and we keep more than 150 beds in our office so we can compare them (and take afternoon naps).
When testing mattresses, we evaluate the following factors:
- Construction: We cut mattresses open to see what’s inside and how they’re made.
- Feel: We check if it has a stuck-in-the-mud memory foam feel, or if it’s more of a neutral foam or a plush pillow top, etc.
- Firmness: We have our own firmness scale and evaluate how that may vary depending on your body and sleeper type.
- Pressure relief: We test what’s the sweet spot for different body and sleeper types.
- Support and how that changes by body/sleeper type
- Edge Support: This is important for couples who share a bed. Would you roll-out of the bed or can you sleep confidently close to the edges?
- Motion Isolation: We use the water glass test to see how the bed fares with motion transfer. This is another important factor for couples that don’t want to wake up one another when they move.
- Temperature Regulation: We use a temperature gun to evaluate if the bed warms up, stays neutral or actively cools while sleeping.
- Noise: This could be an issue in beds with coils or innerspring.
- Off-Gassing: Some beds could have a smell for a few weeks after unpacking, and we try to warn you about it.
- Company policies: We also consider policies such as shipping, returns, trial period and warranty.
- Value: We look at a bed’s price in the context of what it offers in terms of features and quality of materials and construction.
After considering all these factors, our team picks the best beds for each category. For the Best Mattresses In a Box, we looked for the top-rated beds, unique features or construction and the best value for all types of sleepers. For us, affordability is always a top criteria, and for the best online beds, we tried to focus on those that come under $1,000 for a queen-size.
The point of a bed in a box is convenience. It’s easy to ship, easy to move and easy to set up in your home. They are just like any other bed, they just come in a box. All you have to do is unpack it, get it out of the plastic and then let it settle.
You should expect a bed in a box to last as long as any other bed you should buy. Ultimately, how long a mattress in a box lasts will depend on the materials they are made out of. Memory foam beds might sag quicker than other beds, but coil mattresses and latex beds could last up to 15 years.
Purple does offer bed in a box mattresses. In fact, it’s one of the most popular mattress in a box options on the market. The Purple mattress has the Hyper-Elastic Polymer grid it’s known for and a dual-layer of comfort foam for a base.
Why Trust Us
Get the kind of sleep you’ve only dreamed of with some help from our team of mattress experts. We personally test more than 150 of the best sleep solutions from over 60 leading brands on site, so you can be sure you’re getting unbiased reviews, fair comparisons and personalized recommendations.
The Review Team